Share

cover art for Will John Swinney Face a Westminster Inquiry Over Peter Murrell?

Holyrood Sources

Will John Swinney Face a Westminster Inquiry Over Peter Murrell?

Season 5, Ep. 30

The Scottish Parliament is running, but is it actually getting anything done? In this episode of Holyrood Sources, Calum Macdonald, Geoff Aberdein, and Andy Maciver dive into a massive week for Scottish politics.


As Scottish Labour forces a vote on a parliamentary inquiry into Peter Murrell’s embezzlement from the SNP, First Minister John Swinney faces intense pressure over his handling of the situation. Should he have brought in a KC to clean house, or is he right to treat it as "case closed"?


We break down the constitutional battle brewing as Westminster's Scottish Affairs Committee threatens to step in.


Plus, we expose a glaring economic contradiction at the heart of the Scottish Government: debating wealth taxes one week and demanding economic growth the next.


We also react to a brilliant, straight-talking 6-point listener manifesto for the SNP, debate the failure of elected committee conveners, and unpack the transport chaos plaguing Scotland.

---


Subscribe to our mailing list at holyroodsources.com

Email us with thoughts, questions and your own analysis: hello@holyroodsources.com

Drop us a Voice Note or WhatsApp: 0333 404 6507

More episodes

View all episodes

  • 31. Can the Tories Steal Stephen Flynn’s Old Seat?

    41:19||Season 5, Ep. 31
    The Tartan Army takes over Boston, a knife-edge by-election battle in Aberdeen South, and a potential Labour coronation looming in Makerfield. In this episode of Holyrood Sources, Calum Macdonald, Geoff Aberdein, and Andy Maciver dive into a massive week of political drama across Scotland and the wider UK. Fresh off his travels to see Scotland play Haiti at the 2026 World Cup, Geoff gives an insider look at Scotland’s massive "soft power" and how it ties into John Swinney’s economic push in the US.Then, the team unpacks this week's critical Westminster by-elections. In Aberdeen South, Stephen Flynn’s old constituency is turning into an absolute two-horse race between the SNP and the Scottish Conservatives—where energy policy, the oil and gas sector, and the rise of Reform UK could entirely dictate the outcome. Meanwhile, is Arbroath and Broughty Ferry a guaranteed SNP hold despite ongoing party turmoil?Finally, we head south to Makerfield, where Andy Burnham is dicing with political destiny. If Burnham wins, are we heading for a bloody leadership battle against Keir Starmer, or an outright coronation? And what does a potential Burnham premiership mean for Scottish devolution and fiscal autonomy?Follow Holyrood Sources on X/Twitter: @HolyroodSources#ScottishPolitics #HolyroodSources #AndyBurnham #KeirStarmer #SNP #ScottishConservatives #AberdeenSouth #MakerfieldByElection #WorldCup2026
  • 29. Jack McConnell, Alex Cole-Hamilton & Ivan McKee | Scotland 2050

    01:09:16||Season 5, Ep. 29
    On today's episode of Holyrood Sources, Calum Macdonald and Andy Maciver record live from The Assembly Rooms in Edinburgh at the Scotland 2050 Conference.The conference brings together people from the world of business, politics and civic society to discuss Scotland's long term potential.Former First Minister Lord Jack McConnell, Scottish Lib-Dem Leader Alex Cole-Hamilton and Cabinet Secretary for Public Service Reform Ivan McKee join Calum and Andy. They discuss where the country sits after the 2026 Scottish Parliament election and how politicians can start to look at the big picture.Is Scotland in need of total public service reform?Will Peter Murrell's guilty plea hurt Scottish politics in the long term, and would a parliamentary inquiry help?How does the new cabinet balance providing high quality public services whilst maintaining the Scottish economy?
  • 28. Peter Murrell Pleads Guilty, John Swinney's New Cabinet and Tony Blair

    52:09||Season 5, Ep. 28
    On today's episode of the Holyrood Sources podcast Calum Macdonald, Geoff Aberdein and Andy Maciver break down a bombshell week in Scottish politics.Peter Murrell has pleaded guilty to embezzlement from the SNP. What does this mean for the party, The First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon and trust in politics in general?John Swinney has also appointed his new Scottish Cabinet, was his new slimmed down top team the right way to go?How will Stephen Flynn and Stephen Gethins perform in their new Holyrood roles.How will Ivan McKee do after being promoted to Cabinet Secretary for Public Service reform? You can listen to our 2025 interview with him here:https://open.spotify.com/episode/1EO5bkEpwRRPpjnYeOL81I?si=-YP5RgaGSAKtH_d3RoVaMQAnd what does Tony Blair's intervention this week mean for the UK Labour Party, is it time to start listening to the former Prime Minister?
  • 27. Scotland's New MSPs: Live from Edinburgh Gin Distillery

    50:00||Season 5, Ep. 27
    On this special live episode of Holyrood Sources: Calum Macdonald, Geoff Aberdein and Andy Maciver are joined by MSPs, journalists and backroom staff at the Edinburgh Gin Distillery, a stone's throw from The Scottish Parliament. They are joined by three brand new MSPs from the three biggest parties at Holyrood to discuss what the next five years could bring: Katherine Sangster from Scottish Labour, Reform UK Scotland Leader Malcolm Offord and former SNP Westminster Leader Stephen Flynn. What does the future hold for Anas Sarwar and Keir Starmer? Can either survive after devastating results across the UK and in Scotland. Will Reform be the foxes in the hen house... are they as cunning as they make out to be? How does the SNP actually get stuff done, and how does Stephen Flynn live up to his promise as a "champion" of Aberdeen's oil and gas industry. This Holyrood Sources live event was sponsored by Scottish Renewables and SSE.
  • 26. Sources Crossover: Calum Macdonald and Andy Maciver on the GB election results

    36:39||Season 5, Ep. 26
    On this special edition of Stormont Sources, Calum Macdonald and Andy Maciver from the Whitehall Sources and Holyrood Sources podcasts join David McCann, Tim Cairns and Michael McKernan to discuss how the results of the Welsh, Scottish and English elections will impact the UK as a whole and Northern Ireland. What will 3 nationalist First Ministers do for the state of the union... and is that statistic misleading? Where do Reform UK lie after an excellent night of resultsCan Keir Starmer survive as Prime Minister? Stormont Sources is the place to hear all about politics and policy making in Northern Ireland. . Join journalist, David McCann, plus Tim Cairns, a former Special Advisor to First Minister Peter Robinson and Head of Policy for the DUP and Micheal McKernan, a former Special Advisor in the SDLP who worked in the Northern Ireland Executive from 2007-2016.Whitehall Sources brings you insider coverage of Westminster, and Senedd Sources takes you inside politics in Wales. Subscribe to all four podcasts on YouTube and your podcast app to never miss a moment from across UK politics.
  • 25. A New Scottish Parliament: Cross-Party Talks and Your Election Questions Answered

    54:40||Season 5, Ep. 25
    On today’s episode of Holyrood Sources, Calum Macdonald, Geoff Aberdein and Andy Maciver analyse the results of the 2026 Scottish Parliament election and what comes next for Scottish politics. The Prime Minister and the First Minister are set to meet next month, will talks lead to a second independence referendum? Will Keir Starmer even be in office to meet John Swinney? They also discuss the SNP Leader's post-election meetings with political parties, and his refusal to meet with Reform. hHas he shot himself in the foot politically?, and how should the other parties approach these meetings?Calum, Geoff and Andy also take a look at your post-election questions as the picture of the next five years of Scottish politics starts to become clear.
  • 24. Scottish Election Results Live from Holyrood

    01:06:03||Season 5, Ep. 24
    The votes are in, and the map of Scotland has been redrawn. Join the Holyrood Sources team for a deep-dive into the 2026 Scottish Parliament election results.In this special episode, Calum Macdonald, Geoff Aberdein (former Chief of Staff to the First Minister Alex Salmond), and Andy Maciver (former Scottish Conservative Director of Communications) break down a historic night at Holyrood. The Reform UK Surge: How did Malcolm Offord’s party become a major force in the Scottish Parliament?The Pro-Independence Majority: With the Scottish Greens seeing significant gains, how will the SNP-Green dynamic work in this new session?Labour and Tory Losses: Analysis of a difficult night for Anas Sarwar and Russell Findlay as the political center ground shifts.What Happens Next? From coalition talks to the future of the Union, we provide the "inside track" analysis you won't get anywhere else.Holyrood Sources brings you political commentary from those who have lived it. No spin, just the reality of how power works in Scotland.Join the Conversation.Follow us on X/Twitter @HolyroodSources#ScottishElection2026 #Holyrood #SNP #ScottishPolitics #ReformUK #JohnSwinney #AnasSarwar #ScotlandResults #HolyroodSources** The Holyrood Sources podcast brings the best analysis of Scottish politics with those who have lived it as Special Advisers, and those who are current and former politicians and political party leaders. Join Calum Macdonald, Geoff Aberdein (Former Chief of Staff to First Minister Alex Salmond) and Andy Maciver (Former Director of Communications for the Scottish Conservatives).Subscribe nowApple: https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/holyrood-sources/id1673972192Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/4Fj3emmRONEr8aSkhcMgoH?si=789c7874034340c6
  • 23. The End of the Campaign: Poll Trends, Key Moments & Surprises

    51:25||Season 5, Ep. 23
    It's the day before the 2026 Scottish Parliament election! This episode of Holyrood Sources looks back at the campaign.Calum Macdonald is joined by Geoff Aberdein and Andy Maciver to analyse the latest polling trends, what’s really happening beneath the headline numbers,Is SNP support as solid as it seems?Why the list vote could be the real danger zone for the SNPThe rise of Reform UK — protest vote or lasting force?Are Labour and the Conservatives heading for historic lows?We also revisit the defining moments of the campaign — from fiery debate clashes to the surreal whisky tariff saga — and ask whether any of it has actually cut through with voters.And in a special segment, journalism student Logan Smith puts the team on the spot with questions about Reform UK, the future of conservatism in Scotland, and what comes next for Scottish politics.With low turnout expected and tight margins across the board, could results night deliver some major surprises?Don’t miss our LIVE results stream from outside the Scottish Parliament, Friday at 7pm.