Share

cover art for The Vietnam War Unveiled: The Messy Truth with Dr. Robert Thompson

History Rage

The Vietnam War Unveiled: The Messy Truth with Dr. Robert Thompson

Season 14, Ep. 5

In this fiery episode of History Rage, we delve into the most contentious conflict in American history: the Vietnam War. Host Paul Bavill is joined by Dr. Robert Thompson, historian, documentary maker, and author of "Clear, Hold and Destroy," to dismantle the myths surrounding this divisive war.


Unmasking the Myths:

- Dr. Thompson challenges the simplistic good vs. evil narrative often associated with the Vietnam War.

- We explore the complexities of the conflict, including the roles of the United States, South Vietnam, and North Vietnam.


The Roots of Conflict:

- Discover how America initially got involved in Vietnam, starting from its support of French Indochina to its direct military engagement.

- Dr. Thompson explains the geopolitical stakes and the domino theory that drove U.S. involvement.


South Vietnam's Struggles:

- Examine the internal challenges faced by the South Vietnamese government, including corruption and ineffective leadership.

- Understand the impact of these issues on the broader war effort.


The Role of ARVN:

- Debunking the myth that the Army of the Republic of Vietnam (ARVN) was passive and ineffective.

- Highlighting key battles and contributions of ARVN troops.


American Strategy and Public Opinion:

- A look at the U.S. military strategy and the often misunderstood objectives of battles like Khe Sanh and Hamburger Hill.

- The impact of media coverage and public opinion on the war effort.


My Lai and War Crimes:

- Addressing the infamous My Lai Massacre and its repercussions on American and global perceptions of the war.

- Dr. Thompson discusses the complexities of war crimes and the U.S. military's response.


Conclusion:

- Reflecting on the enduring legacy of the Vietnam War and the importance of understanding its complexities.

- Dr. Thompson urges listeners to look beyond simplistic narratives and appreciate the multifaceted nature of historical events.


For further insights, grab a copy of Dr. Robert Thompson's "Clear, Hold and Destroy" from The History Rage Bookshop and follow him on Twitter @DrRobThompson.


Don't forget to share your thoughts on Twitter @HistoryRage using the hashtag #HistoryRage. Join our 'Angry Mob' on Patreon for exclusive perks, including early episode access and the esteemed History Rage mug, at patreon.com/historyrage.


Follow History Rage on Social Media

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/HistoryRage

Twitter: https://twitter.com/HistoryRage

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/historyrage/

Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/historyrage.bsky.social


Stay Angry, Stay Informed - History Rage

More episodes

View all episodes

  • 4. Bloody No More: Reassessing Mary I with Dr. Johanna Strong

    57:06||Season 15, Ep. 4
    Get ready to ignite your historical curiosity! Host Paul Bavill welcomes early modern historian and teacher of history and politics, Dr. Johanna Strong, to confront the myths and misconceptions surrounding Tudor women, particularly Henry VIII's daughters. Prepare for an explosive discussion that dismantles the infamous reputation of Mary I, often known as "Bloody Mary."Raging Against the Bloody Narrative:- Dr. Johanna Strong passionately debunks the myth of "Bloody Mary," arguing for a more nuanced understanding of Mary I's reign and legacy.- Discover why Mary I is often misunderstood and how her actions were consistent with the norms of her time, despite being vilified by Protestant historians.Mary's Fight for Legitimacy:- Learn about the political and religious challenges Mary I faced upon ascending the throne, including her struggle against Lady Jane Grey and the need to assert her legitimacy.- Explore the complex dynamics of Mary's reign, from her efforts to restore Catholicism to her significant contributions to governance and military reform.Diplomatic Triumphs and Missteps:- Understand Mary's diplomatic achievements, including her marriage to Philip of Spain, which positioned her as a powerful European monarch.- Examine the loss of Calais and its impact on Mary's legacy, as well as her efforts to stabilise England during tumultuous times.Rewriting Mary's Legacy:- Delve into how Elizabeth I and later Protestant historians shaped Mary's negative image, overshadowing her accomplishments and contributions.- Dr. Strong calls for a re-evaluation of Mary's reign, urging listeners to view her within the context of her time and recognise her role in paving the way for Elizabeth I's success.Join us as Dr. Johanna Strong brings to light the complexities of Mary I's reign, challenging the "Bloody Mary" stereotype and advocating for a more balanced historical perspective. Follow Johanna on Twitter at @jo_strong_ and explore her academic work at drjohannastrong.ca.Support the rage that fuels our historical deep dives at patreon.com/historyrage, and don't forget to leave us a review on Apple Podcasts, Podchaser, or Spotify.To catch up on all the rage from bygone times, visit our website at www.historyrage.comIf you want to get in touch with History Rage, email historyragepod@gmail.comFollow History Rage on Social MediaFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/HistoryRageTwitter: https://twitter.com/HistoryRageInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/historyrage/Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/historyrage.bsky.social Stay informed, stay passionate, and let the rage for truth in history rage on!
  • 3. Corsairs, Not Pirates - The True Tales of Malta's Maritime History with Liam Gauci

    54:08||Season 15, Ep. 3
    Prepare to have your nautical myths shattered in this swashbuckling episode of History Rage! Host Paul Bavill is joined by Liam Gauci, historian and curator of the Malta Maritime Museum, to delve into the murky waters of piracy and privateering in the Mediterranean. The Corsair Conundrum:- Liam passionately dismantles the common misconception that corsairs were simply pirates, clarifying the significant legal distinctions that separated privateers and corsairs from their pirate counterparts.- Discover the intricate international maritime laws that governed corsair activities, turning them into prisoners of war rather than criminals destined for the gallows. Malta: The Corsair Haven:- Explore how Malta's strategic location made it a bustling hub for privateers from all over Europe, including British, French, Russian, and Spanish corsairs.- Learn about the economic and social impact of corsairing on the island, from the service industry to the grand investments that fuelled these maritime ventures. Tales of the High Seas:- Liam shares riveting stories of famous Maltese corsairs, like Guglielmo Lorenzi, whose daring exploits earned him a gold medal and a legendary status.- Hear about the remarkable characters who navigated the fine line between legality and piracy, including magicians, dandy captains, and those who switched allegiances with the changing tides of war. The End of an Era:- Understand how the Crimean War and subsequent treaties brought an end to privateering, reshaping Malta's economy and its role in global maritime history. Join us as Liam Gauci unleashes his rage against historical inaccuracies, advocating for a nuanced understanding of corsairs and their lawful plundering. To dive deeper into this fascinating subject, visit the Malta Maritime Museum at www.maltamaritimemuseum.mt and follow Liam on Twitter @liamgauci13. Support the rage that fuels our historical deep dives at patreon.com/historyrage, and don't forget to leave us a review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. Stay informed, stay passionate, and let the rage for truth in history rage on! To catch up on all the rage from bygone times go to the website www.historyrage.com If you want to get in touch with History Rage then email historyragepod@gmail.com Follow History Rage on Social MediaFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/HistoryRageTwitter: https://twitter.com/HistoryRageInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/historyrage/Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/historyrage.bsky.social
  • LIVE SPECIAL : D-Day Dodgers, Mark Clark, and Myths of the Italian Campaign with James Holland

    43:07|
    In this lively episode of History Rage Live, host Paul Bavill welcomes back the legendary historian, author, and podcaster James Holland. Known for his compelling narratives and deep dives into World War II history, Holland joins the podcast to discuss the often misunderstood Italian Campaign of the Second World War. With a focus on debunking myths and setting the record straight, Holland sheds light on the strategic importance and challenges of the Italian front.Episode Highlights:Mark Clark's Misunderstood Legacy: James Holland passionately defends General Mark Clark, dispelling myths about his role in the Italian Campaign and addressing misconceptions about his decisions and actions.The Italian Campaign's Strategic Importance: Explore why the Italian front was crucial for the Allies, focusing on its role in diverting German forces and the significance of capturing the Foggia airfields.The Battle of Monte Cassino: Delve into the infamous battle, understanding its strategic complexities and the mountainous terrain that made it a formidable challenge for Allied forces.Stalin and the Italian Front: Discover how the Soviet Union viewed the Italian Campaign and their interest in expanding influence in post-war Italy.The Challenges of Amphibious Operations: Learn about the logistical constraints faced by the Allies, including the shortage of landing craft and the impact on strategic decisions.Evolution of Historical Perspectives: Holland reflects on how his understanding of the Italian Campaign has evolved over two decades, providing insights into the complexities of wartime strategy and the broader context of World War II.Join us as we unravel the layers of historical distortion and gain a clearer understanding of the Italian Campaign's pivotal role in World War II. James Holland's insights promise to challenge long-held beliefs and illuminate the nuanced realities of this often-overlooked theatre of war.Connect with James Holland:- Follow James on Twitter: @James1940Support the Show:If you’re fired up by this episode, consider joining the 'Angry Mob' on Patreon at patreon.com/historyrage for exclusive content, early access, and the iconic History Rage mug.James’s Latest Book: Cassino '44: Five Months of Hell in ItalyFollow the Rage:Twitter: @HistoryRageFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/HistoryRageInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/historyrage/Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/historyrage.bsky.socialFrom all of us at History Rage, stay curious, stay passionate, and most importantly, stay angry!
  • 2. Model Occupation Myth: The Harsh Reality of the Channel Islands with Nick Le Huray

    50:34||Season 15, Ep. 2
    In this fiery episode of History Rage, host Paul Bavill welcomes back historian and podcaster Nick Le Huray to dismantle the myth of the "model occupation" of the Channel Islands during World War II. Together, they delve into the harsh realities faced by the islanders under German occupation, a far cry from the benign narrative often portrayed.The Myth of the Model Occupation:- Nick passionately debunks the notion that the German occupation of the Channel Islands was a "model" occupation, revealing the severe hardships and brutal treatment endured by the islanders.- Explore the evidence that contradicts the idea that the Germans behaved themselves on British soil, including deportations, hostages, and severe restrictions on daily life.Life Under Occupation:- Discover the day-to-day struggles of the islanders, from food shortages and confiscated property to the constant threat of imprisonment and deportation.- Hear about the acts of defiance and resistance, including illicit newspapers and sabotage, that challenged the German occupiers despite the immense risks involved.Uncovering the Truth:- Nick shares his extensive research from unpublished diaries, family stories, and newly available archives that paint a vivid picture of the true nature of the occupation.- Learn about the impact of Nazi racial policies on the islanders, including the deportation of Jews and the horrific treatment of slave workers.The Legacy of Resistance:- Understand the long-lasting consequences for those accused of collaboration and the efforts to mitigate German demands by the local civilian government.- Nick highlights the importance of challenging the simplistic narratives and recognising the complex and often brutal reality of the occupation.Prepare to have your perceptions shattered as Nick Le Huray brings to light the untold stories of defiance and suffering during the German occupation of the Channel Islands. For more on this topic, check out Nick's blog at islandfortress.com and his podcast, Islands at War, available on all major platforms.Follow Nick on Twitter @nicklehSupport History Rage on Patreon at patreon.com/historyrage for exclusive content and the coveted History Rage mug.Follow History Rage on Social Media:Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/HistoryRageTwitter: https://twitter.com/HistoryRageInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/historyrage/Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/historyrage.bsky.socialStay informed, stay impassioned, and let the rage for historical truth burn on!
  • 1. The Real Anne of Cleves: Beyond the Flanders Mare with Heather Darsie

    44:02||Season 15, Ep. 1
    Step into the tumultuous world of the Tudor court with this riveting episode of History Rage. Host Paul Bavill is joined by Heather Darsie, author of "Anna: Duchess of Cleves" and "Children of the House of Cleves," as well as the upcoming "Stuart Spouses," to debunk the myths surrounding Anne of Cleves and shed light on the reality of her life and legacy. The Misunderstood Queen:- Heather Darsie tackles the persistent and unfair label of Anne of Cleves as the "Flanders Mare," revealing the true origins and inaccuracies of this nickname.Historical Catfishing Unveiled:- Discover the truth behind Henry VIII's annulment from Anne, including the political and personal motivations that led to this decision, and why Anne was never actually called "ugly" by Henry.Anne's Early Life and Education:- Heather delves into Anne's upbringing in the German court, debunking myths about her education and revealing the rich cultural context of her youth.Political Intrigues and Alliances:- Explore the complex political landscape of the Holy Roman Empire and how Anne's marriage was intended to solidify alliances, rather than being a simple Protestant match.Life After the Annulment:- Learn about Anne's life post-annulment, her status as Henry's "beloved sister," and her relationships with Mary I and Elizabeth I, as well as the challenges she faced during Edward VI's reign.Reevaluating Anne's Legacy:- Heather calls for a more nuanced understanding of historical figures, urging listeners to see Anne of Cleves as a real person with a complex life, rather than a caricature.Join us for this enlightening episode as we strip away the layers of myth and misrepresentation to reveal the true story of Anne of Cleves. For those eager to dive deeper, Heather's books offer a treasure trove of insights and are available through the History Rage bookshop.Order Anna, Duchess of Cleves: The King's 'Beloved Sister'Follow Heather on Twitter @hdarsiehistory, and on Instagram at hdarsiehistory. You can also read her articles at maidensandmanuscripts.com.Support our quest for historical truth on Patreon. For £5 per month, gain early access to episodes, livestreams, entry into prize draws, the chance to pose questions to future guests, and the coveted History Rage mug. Subscribe at patreon.com/historyrage. Stay informed, stay passionate, and most importantly, stay angry!
  • Intro to Series 15

    01:56||Season 15, Ep. 0
    Welcome to Series 15 of History Rage! A massive thank you to everyone who has supported us on this journey—your encouragement means the world. Here's a sneak peek at the fiery topics we'll be tackling over the next ten weeks. Get ready to challenge everything you thought you knew about history.Upcoming Rages:Heather Darsie takes on Anne of Cleves and the 'Flanders Mare' mythNick Le Huray gets his rage on at the 'Model Occupation' of the Channel; IslandsMuseum Curator Liam Gauci of the Malta Maritime Museum rages that Corsairs and Pirates are very differentJohanna Strong is sick to death of the Bloody Mary tagTobias Capwell rages that armour is for fighting in, of course you can move in itSteve Tibble argues about the realities of the Crusades and their missionAuthor Ron Drabkin takes a new look at the Pearl Harbour blame game and who was at faultShalina Patel shouts that there are many more suffrage campaigners than the PankhurstsNicola Clark rages that Anne Boleyn did not withhold sex to become QueenJames Crossland explores the farce that is the Lockhart plot and that British Intelligence is not infallibleThe ragefires will burn again with general release on 16th December. See you then!Stay Connected:Follow us on Twitter: @HistoryRageJoin the conversation with Paul Bavill: @PaulBavillShare your thoughts using the hashtag #HistoryRageSupport History Rage on Patreon for early episode access, the chance to submit questions to guests, prize draws, and the exclusive History Rage mug at www.patreon.com/historyrage.To catch up on all the rage from bygone times, visit our website www.historyrage.comIf you want to get in touch with History Rage, email historyragepod@gmail.comStay Angry, Stay Informed - History Rage
  • 10. The Sailors’ Stories: The Navy's Role in Normandy with Nick Hewitt

    56:19||Season 14, Ep. 10
    In this episode, historian and author Nick Hewitt shares his expertise on the role of sailors in the Normandy invasion during World War II. He debunks the misconception that sailors only put the army on the beach and then left. ·        The Navy was involved in maintaining supply lines, providing naval gunfire support, and defending against German attacks.·        Intelligence gathering and preparation, including the work of the Combined Operations Pilotage Parties, were essential before D-Day.·        Their responsibilities included delivering troops to the beaches, coordinating the movement of ships and supplies, providing naval gunfire support, and establishing and maintaining the Mulberry Harbours.·        The Navy had beach masters and tri-service beach groups that organized the traffic and logistics on the beaches.·        There were forward observer teams that called in naval gunfire support and sailors who cleared and operated captured ports.Connect with Nick:·        - Follow Nick on Twitter: @nickhweitt4Support the Show:·        If you’re fired up by this episode, consider joining the 'Angry Mob' on Patreon at patreon.com/historyrage for exclusive content, early access, and the iconic History Rage mug.Nick’s Books·        Normandy: the Sailors' Story: A Naval History of D-Day and the Battle for France·        Coastal Convoys 1939-1945: The Indestructible Highway·        Firing on Fortress Europe: HMS Belfast on D-Day Follow the Rage:·        - Twitter: @HistoryRage·        - Paul on Twitter: @PaulBavill·        Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/HistoryRage·        Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/historyrage/·        Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/historyrage.bsky.socialFrom all of us at History Rage, stay curious, stay passionate, and most importantly, stay angry!
  • 9. The Myths of Mata Hari and Edith Cavell with Helen Fry

    43:21||Season 14, Ep. 9
    In this episode of History Rage, historian Dr. Helen Fry discusses the misconceptions surrounding Mata Hari and Edith Cavell. She reveals that Mata Hari was not a spy, despite popular belief, and that her image as a glamorous femme fatale has overshadowed the contributions of real women in intelligence. On the other hand, Edith Cavell, known as an innocent martyr, was actually involved in espionage and ran her own network behind enemy lines in Belgium. Dr. Fry emphasizes the importance of uncovering the true stories of women in intelligence and dispelling myths that have persisted for decades.HighlightsMata Hari was not a spy, despite popular belief, and her image as a glamorous femme fatale has overshadowed the contributions of real women in intelligence.Edith Cavell, known as an innocent martyr, was actually involved in espionage and ran her own network behind enemy lines in Belgium.It is important to uncover the true stories of women in intelligence and dispel myths that have persisted for decades.The public is hungry for new stories and properly researched history that challenges traditional narratives.Connect with Dr. Helen Fry:- Follow Helen on Twitter: @drhelenfrySupport the Show:If you’re fired up by this episode, consider joining the 'Angry Mob' on Patreon at patreon.com/historyrage for exclusive content, early access, and the iconic History Rage mug.Helen’s BooksWomen in IntelligenceThe Walls Have Ears: The Greatest Intelligence Operation of World War IISpymaster: The Man Who Saved MI6MI9: A History of the Secret Service for Escape and Evasion in World War TwoThe London Cage: The Secret History of Britain's World War II Interrogation Centre Follow the Rage:- Twitter: @HistoryRage- Paul on Twitter: @PaulBavillFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/HistoryRageInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/historyrage/Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/historyrage.bsky.socialFrom all of us at History Rage, stay curious, stay passionate, and most importantly, stay angry!
  • 8. The Neutrality Nightmare: Debunking Irish WWII Myths with Dr. Joseph Quinn

    01:13:56||Season 14, Ep. 8
    **LANGUAGE WARNING**In this explosive episode of History Rage, host Paul Bavill is joined by the impassioned Dr. Joseph Quinn, a historian specialising in Ireland and Britain during the Second World War. Together, they tackle one of the most contentious and misunderstood aspects of the war: Irish neutrality. Dr. Quinn, known for his fiery takes, is here to set the record straight on the myths and misconceptions surrounding Ireland's stance during the conflict. Episode Highlights:- Dr. Joseph Quinn's Return: Dr. Quinn is back, bringing his expertise on the Second World War and Irish history to the forefront.- The Roots of Irish Neutrality: Discover how Ireland's decision to remain neutral was not an act of cowardice but a calculated move to preserve national security and avoid civil conflict.- Debunking Myths: Dr. Quinn dismantles the erroneous belief that Ireland was a haven for Nazi sympathisers and collaborators, providing compelling evidence to the contrary.- Pro-Allied Neutrality: Learn about the extensive, albeit covert, cooperation between Ireland and the Allied forces, including intelligence sharing and the facilitation of Irish volunteers joining the British military.- The Book of Condolence: Addressing one of the most persistent myths, Dr. Quinn clarifies the reality behind De Valera's controversial visit to the German representative following Hitler's death.- Churchill's Critique and De Valera's Response: Delve into the diplomatic tensions between Ireland and Britain, highlighted by Churchill's post-war speech and De Valera's poignant reply.Join us as we navigate through the murky waters of historical distortion and emerge with a clearer understanding of Ireland's complex role during the Second World War. This episode promises to be a rollercoaster of revelations, challenging long-held beliefs and shining a light on the nuanced reality of Irish neutrality. Connect with Dr. Joseph Quinn:- Follow Dr. Quinn on Twitter: @ww2researchSupport the Show:If you’re fired up by this episode, consider joining the 'Angry Mob' on Patreon at patreon.com/historyrage for exclusive content, early access, and the iconic History Rage mug. Follow the Rage:- Twitter: @HistoryRage- Paul on Twitter: @PaulBavillFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/HistoryRageInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/historyrage/Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/historyrage.bsky.socialFrom all of us at History Rage, stay curious, stay passionate, and most importantly, stay angry!