Share

cover art for What if the Indian Rebellion had succeeded? British OUT but a broken nation emerges

History Undone

What if the Indian Rebellion had succeeded? British OUT but a broken nation emerges

Season 2, Ep. 20
•

On this episode of History Undone, Fergus Macphee is joined by Rear Admiral Dr Chris Parry and Professor Chandrika Kaul from the University of St Andrews to discuss one of the most important events in the history of modern India and Imperial Britain: the Rebellion of 1857. Also referred to as the 'mutiny', it began on the 10 May when Sepoy soldiers rose up in the city of Meerut near Delhi. A day later they had captured Delhi, before pushing. What started with soldiers, grew to include civilians and peasants and despite the British East India Company quashing it after 18 months, the EIC was dissolved and the British crown took direct rule of the country.


The rebellion has a hugely influential and lasting legacy today, but what if it had succeeded? This is History Undone.

More episodes

View all episodes

  • The Blitz, invasion, nuclear threat... could Britain today actually survive anything? | Origins

    27:31|
    On this episode of Origins, Fergus Macphee is joined once again by Rear Admiral Dr Chris Parry to discuss the British government's new 'be ready' campaign in case of emergencies. It's not the first time in history government's have put their public on high alert, but in 2026 is anybody listening? This is Origins.
  • Is Europe on the Brink of Another 1848 Revolution? | Origins

    26:48|
    On this episode of Origins, Fergus Macphee is joined by Rear Admiral Dr Chris Parry to discuss the wave of protest sweeping Europe. Is it a repeat of the 1848 revolutions, or something else entirely? This is Origins.
  • 27. What if Britain had LOST the Boer Wars? WWI powers turn on the British Empire

    59:26||Season 2, Ep. 27
    On this episode of History Undone, Fergus Macphee is joined once again by Rear Admiral Dr Chris Parry and Dr Spencer Jones to discuss what could have become one of the biggest military embarrassments for the British Empire. Also called the South African War, or the Anglo-Boer war, it was a bloody and drawn out conflict that shaped the future of modern South Africa. Yet had the British lost, its impact could have reached far and wide, into the First World War and beyond. This is History Undone.
  • A 21st Century Yalta: Are Trump, Putin & Xi about to CARVE UP Ukraine? | Origins

    36:21|
    On this episode of Origins, Fergus Macphee is joined by Rear Admiral Dr Chris Parry to discuss a potential meeting between Xi Jinping, Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin next month where they could discuss a plan for the future of Ukraine. In February 1945, 'the big three' of Winston Churchill, Franklin D. Roosevelt and Joseph Stalin met in Yalta to discuss future European borders after the Second World War. It was an imperfect arrangement that saw Germany punished, but Poland carved up and Stalin satisfied. If this happens in 2026, Ukraine will not be at the table - so what can we learn from the past? This is Origins.
  • From Chernobyl to plague: A history of Russian cover-ups | Origins

    30:11|
    On this episode of History Undone: Origins, Fergus Macphee is joined by author and host of Silicon Curtain podcast Jonathan Fink. They discuss the reported outbreak of plague from an institution in Russia which has led to the death of a lab worker. Yet nothing is certain, due in part to unclear messaging from the government. This is hardly the first time Russian or Soviet Union administration's have not been fully transparent. This is Origins.
  • How the Houthis became a problem Saudi Arabia can't solve | Origins

    30:16|
    On this episode of History Undone: Origins, Fergus Macphee speaks with Professor Thomas Juneau from the University of Ottawa to discuss the history of the Houthis and how their influence has grown. Far from just being rebels in Yemen, the group are now a regional power, causing difficulty to Saudi Arabia and the US. Yet how did we get here? This is Origins.
  • 26. What if France had WON the Franco-Prussian War? An entirely new 20th Century

    01:01:55||Season 2, Ep. 26
    On this edition of History Undone, Fergus Macphee is joined once again by Rear Admiral Dr Chris Parry to discuss one of the most overlooked, but important conflicts of the last 200 years: the Franco-Prussian War. What was supposed to be a chance for Napoleon III to reassert French dominance on the continent, quickly turned into a total nightmare. Poor planning and chaotic strategy saw the French routed in a matter of weeks, before Paris was beseiged. Yet on the Prussian side, this led to the unification of Germany and the creation of the first German Empire, with lasting ramifications across the globe. So what if France had won? This is History Undone.
  • Without the 1789 Revolution, would France be protesting today? | Origins

    25:55|
    On this episode of Origins, Fergus Macphee is joined by Emeritus Professor of history at The University of Melbourne and an expert on the French Revolutionm, Professor Peter McPhee. They discuss the current protest that have swept through France and, in some places turned violent. The country is used to large-scale demonstrations, but can this be traced back to the Revolution and do the French really take to the streets as much as people think? This is Origins.
  • How the Royal Navy collapsed from 1,400 ships to 60 | Origins

    31:16|
    Welcome to the first episode of History Undone: Origins. This is the space we will be discussing current affairs and geopolitics, through our historical and counterfactual lense. For the first episode, Fergus Macphee is joined by Rear Admiral Dr Chris Parry to discuss the decline of the Royal Navy. Rather than one event, this is a story of managed decline over the course of 85 years, but can it all be traced back to 1945? This is Origins.