Share

cover art for Pauline Kael's Brutal Reviews Changed Hollywood

Directora

Pauline Kael's Brutal Reviews Changed Hollywood

Season 1, Ep. 6
•

"She's so f***ing mean," Quentin Tarantino once said of film critic Pauline Kael. Kael was known for brutally harsh film reviews that could make or break a movie. People want to dismiss critics for "not knowing anything", but Kael knew a lot - and her knowledge was valuable to the industry. Her ability to spot up-and-coming talent in the 60s and 70s helped New American Cinema flourish. Find out about her life as we read her wildest reviews. Who could ever say something mean about The Sound of Music? Pauline Kael!


This episode originally aired with Grab Bag Collab on their Patreon. Stephanie Weber is the host, creator, researcher, and writer of Directora. Amanda Rossman mixed this episode. Brock Alter made the artwork. Follow Directora on Instagram and TikTok. E-mail questions, suggestions, and anything else to directorapodcast@gmail.com


Sources for this episode:


Barsanti, Chris. “When Film Mattered: Pauline Kael’s Age of Movies.” October 27, 2011. https://themillions.com/2011/10/when-film-mattered-pauline-kaels-the-age-of-movies.html


Brody, Richard. “What Pauline Kael Failed to See About Young Film Lovers”. April 8, 2025. https://www.newyorker.com/culture/the-front-row/what-pauline-kael-failed-to-see-about-young-film-lovers


Cwik, Greg. “The Critic as Artful Gadfly”. Pop Matters. November 14, 2012. https://www.popmatters.com/165416-the-critic-as-artful-gadfly-pauline-kael-2495797841.html


Garver, Rob. What She Said: The Art of Pauline Kael. (2018).


Hellerman, Jason. “The Controversy Behind ‘Citizen Kane’, ‘Mank’, and Pauline Kael”. December 2, 2020. https://nofilmschool.com/citizen-kane-pauline-kael


Jones, Emma. “It Was Really Wrong: How Last Tango in Paris’ Infamous Explicit Scene Undid Its Female Star.” BBC News. April 3, 2025.  https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20250402-maria-schneider-how-last-tango-in-pariss-infamous-explicit-scene-undid-its-female-star


Kael, Pauline. “Circles and Squares.” JSTOR.org https://www.jstor.org/stable/1210726


Kael, Pauline. “Bonnie and Clyde.” The New Yorker. October 13, 1967. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/1967/10/21/bonnie-and-clyde


Linfield, Susie. “The Perils of Pauline” LA Times. Sept. 29, 2002. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2002-sep-29-bk-linfield29-story.html


Potton, Ed. “She’s So Mean - The Critic Everyone Loved to Hate”. The Times. March 17, 2023. https://www.thetimes.com/culture/film/article/tarantino-described-her-film-reviews-as-the-greatest-shit-ever-she-s-just-being-so-f-ing-mean-nnkt6056r


Russell, Calum. “Pauline Kael Reviews Quentin Tarantino’s Pulp Fiction” Far Out Magazine. March 16 2013. https://faroutmagazine.co.uk/pauline-kael-reviews-quentin-tarantinos-pulp-fiction/


More episodes

View all episodes

  • Documentaries Directed By Women: Part 2

    01:06:52|
    We are back with part 2 of our documentaries mini-series. Honestly, there was so much information that Directora will likely do an entire documentary series in the future, but for now, jump back into docs with us. We go over a few more pioneers, such as Marion and Ruby Grierson, and other directors during WWII. Then we talk about Agnes Varda's The Gleaners and I before getting rock-n-roll with it as we delve into all three of Penelope Spheeris' Decline of Western Civilization films. Then we take a look at political documentaries with Cuba's first female director, Sara Gomez, and Naza. Finally, we explore the world of music documentaries with two very important docs by women: Gimme Shelter and Homecoming. Listen to hear all about these documentaries, these amazing women, and more! Directora was created by Stephanie Weber. She researches, writes, records, and edits all episodes. Follow Directora on social media and email directorapodcast@gmail.com for any questions, comments, or compliments.
  • Bonus: Interview with Actress, Writer, and Producer Kelly O'Malley

    39:44|
    Kelly O'Malley joins us on Directora to talk about her process co-writing, producing, and starring in her new film Wake (directed by Devin M. Schwartz). This dramedy follows siblings in the aftermath of their father's sudden death as they have to come together - and hold it together - for their father's wake. Wake stars Cole Sprouse, Penelope Ann Miller, Riki Lindhome, and Chris Parnell, as well as O'Malley and an ensemble of wonderful actors. Kelly O'Malley also talks about her non-profit A Light in Dark Places, and offers advice on how we can help each other with grief. It's a really good conversation, especially for anyone who has lost a loved one or is interested in developing their own work into a great indie film. I love chatting with people who make their own work because they always offer interesting insight. O'Malley developed this film based on personal events, so she discusses the process of turning tragedy into entertainment. This episode is a must!
  • Mind-Blowing Documentaries Made By Women - Part 1

    59:48|
    One of the best films of the year is a three-hour-long documentary. You Can See Everything, directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, has people talking about the ways in which this documentary did or did not elevate the genre, as well as other mind-blowing documentaries that people should watch. I've loved these discussions, but I noticed some omissions in these discussions...and a lot of them were documentaries made by women. That's too bad considering this is a genre that welcomed women at the helm before other genres did, and a sizable amount of documentaries continue to be produced and directed by women. In today's special episode of Directora, we will look at a few mind-blowing documentaries. This episode talks about Helen Keller: In Her Own Words, Portrait of Jason, The Other Half of the Sky: A China Memoir, Harlan County USA, Not a Pretty Picture, Grey Gardens, and Paris is Burning. Do you think I skipped some important documentaries? Don't worry! I'm going to talk about those in next week's episode. That's right - this is a two-parter!Listen to this episode. Follow us on social media to see clips and stills of the films talked about here. Directora was created by Stephanie Weber. She researches, writes, records, hosts, and edits the episodes. Email directorapodcast@gmail.com for comments, questions, and compliments.
  • 1. Who Was The First Female Filmmaker? (Re-Release)

    20:30||Season 1, Ep. 1
    This is a re-release of the very first episode of Directora! Welcome to Directora! I'm so happy you're here.Host and creator Stephanie Weber introduces herself and the premise of the entire podcast. This podcast celebrates the history of women in film, so it is only fitting that we start with the very beginning of the film industry and the woman believed to be the first female filmmaker in the world.Her name was Alice Guy-Blaché, and she went from being an employee at a camera company in France to the writer, director, and producer of over 1,000 films. Yes, you read that right! She even made films in America in the early 1900s, when her film company set up a second location in the budding East Coast film industry in the United States. Her breakthroughs include the first narrative films, feminist satires, and films featuring the first all-Black casts. This is the astounding story of Alice Guy-Blaché, her contributions to cinema as a whole, and what happened to her towards the end of her life. While many of her films are lost to time, there are several that remain. Please follow us on Instagram (directora_podcast) and TikTok (directorapodcast) to see clips of her films as well as promotional posters and still images.Special thanks to friends Joel Walkowski, John Campogna, Jeff LaPenna, Veronica Hetschinof, Marissa Hansen, Emily Roscoe Jones, Brock Alter, and Alex Van Beek for answering my questions up top. Thank you to Daisy Eagan for editing my script and to Amanda Rossman for the final sound mix. Special thanks to Brock Alter for the art and tech help. It took a village to make this first episode of Directora!Email directorapodcast@gmail.com for questions and compliments.
  • Bonus: Interview with Filmmaker Adell Lashawn

    29:32|
    For our final bonus interview of Halloween season, we talk to Adell Lashawn who writes, produces, and directs horror shorts for an upcoming anthology. Her latest film Don't Open After 3 AM was just released this week and it's the perfect horror short to treat yourself to this Halloween. Adell talks about indie filmmaking, how she got her start learning on-set as an actress and an AD, and what it's like to make movies in Atlanta. She also talks about what's in store for her next! I love talking to indie filmmakers. I always learn something new! Listen to the episode to learn a little something, too. Watch her new film here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jtwk4O5RxREFollow Directora on Instagram and TikTok. Subscribe here to be up-to-date on new episodes!
  • Myths and Urban Legends with Special Guest Kate Haley

    01:06:49|
    For Directora's 31-for-31 horror movie challenge, we watched several films inspired by myths and urban legends: Cropsey, The Daisy Chain, Mother of Flies, and The Lure. That last one is a mermaid horror, something that my good friend Kate Haley has also made a movie about. Kate joins me from Ireland tot alk about Irish folk horror, mermaids, local legends, and more. We have a great time exchanging local lore from both of our places of origin! Listen to hear more - and watch Kate's film A Fairytale Romance to see the mermaid horror for yourself.This is our final Halloween episode, so the episode ends with a summary of the month and a sneak preview into what's next. Keep following Directora for more updates on Instagram and TikTok. Subscribe to the podcast for new episodes!
  • Bonus: Five Nights at Freddy's with Underrated Movie Podcast

    39:07|
    Here's a bonus episode for Halloween week! Five Nights at Freddy's was one of the 31-for-31 horror films this month, featuring horror films directed by women. Derrick McDuff of Underrated Movie Podcast wanted to talk about it, too, so Directora and Underrated joined forces to chat about Five Nights at Freddy's. They talk about the film's strengths and weaknesses, its history, and its legacy, as well as other horror movie topics. Listen to Underrated Movie Podcast wherever you listen to podcasts!
  • Pregnancy Horror with Special Guest Deborah Lee Smith

    55:15|
    Why are there so many pregnancy horror films? And horror films where motherhood is made horrific by an evil child? I wanted to delve into domestic horror and why we've seen so many pregnancy horror films in recent years. Actress and producer Deborah Lee Smith joined me to talk about pregnancy fears - both in film and in real life - and the ways that these are reflected in movies. This was a GREAT conversation as we talked about all things pregnancy and motherhood as they relate to horror. I learned some things about reproductive healthcare that I didn't know! Listen to hear more. Follow Directora on Instagram and TikTok. Email directorapodcast@gmail.com for questions, comments, and compliments. Directora is created, written, hosted, and edited by Stephanie Weber. Artwork by Brock Alter.
  • Bonus: Interview with Director Alison-Eve Hammersley

    31:16|
    For the month of October, Directora is all things women in horror - including talking to directors of cool new horror films! We talked to director Alison-Eve Hammersley about her new found footage horror film Erie. She talked about the process of making the film, what inspired it, and trends in horror that she would love to see more of. Erie is currently doing the festival circuit, so check it out if it is coming to a film festival near you! Follow Directora on Instagram and TikTok for clips and stills from episodes. Email directorapodcast@gmail.com if you have questions, compliments, and comments.