Share

cover art for Stephen McCullagh: What the jury didn't hear in Natalie McNally murder trial

Crime World

Stephen McCullagh: What the jury didn't hear in Natalie McNally murder trial

This episode is brought to you by our sister podcast The BelTel.

Murderer Stephen McCullagh has been aptly described as “a monster hiding in plain sight”.

A week on from his conviction there has been a lot of reaction to the the nerd-culture YouTuber’s conviction of murdering Natalie McNally.

He denied the killing, but the jury unanimously found him guilty in a matter of hours. He has yet to be given his tariff, but Natalie’s family says he should never be let out. 

They say he is simply “too dangerous to let out on the street”.

Meanwhile, the Sunday Life has revealed that a film made by McCullagh as a student chillingly foretold the murder and how he pretended to be one of our journalists to find out what evidence the cops had on him.

The Sunday Life’s Angela Davison joins Ciarán Dunbar with some of the stories which could not be told whilst the trial was ongoing and what has emerged since McCullagh’s conviction.

More episodes

View all episodes

  • How a career criminal known as 'The Vet' was finally caught with €11m of cocaine

    20:56|
    A career criminal and drug trafficker known as 'The Vet' has been jailed for 13 years after being caught with nearly €11 million worth of cocaine. Michael Murphy was caught red-handed with the drugs stash which was hidden in an elaborate secret compartment in his lorry.Niall talks to Crime World’s Ken Foy about how Murphy had been a key figure in the drugs trade for decades.
  • When will James English release the podcast with Daniel Kinahan?

    18:15|
    Podcaster James English has assured fans he will start releasing 20 hours of interview footage and audio with Daniel Kinahan this month.English was recently convicted of domestic abuse on a pregnant ex-partner, he says he has interviewed Kinahan for over 5 years.
  • Gerry ‘The Monk’ Hutch’s son loses appeal over extradition to Ireland

    21:37|
    The son of Gerry ‘The Monk’ Hutch has lost his appeal against extradition to Ireland, where he faces charges under anti-gang legislation and is accused of being part of a corruption ring involving Gardaí allegedly passing information to the Hutch Organised Crime Group.Jason Hutch has said he has no case to answer, while his lawyer has claimed he was targeted because of his father’s election bid.So, what do we know about the case?
  • The Electric Picnic debrief 2026

    12:15|
    The rain tried hard to put a dampener on our Crime World live show this weekend at Electric Picnic but we weathered the storm.Today a weary Niall and Nicola recount their experiences and tell you where you can catch our new show Succession.
  • House of Prayer hoarding millions while volunteers work themselves into hospital

    20:44|
    The controversial House of Prayer are hoarding millions of dollars in assets in the US in cash and properties.And followers of visionary Christina Gallagher there are telling devotees that they need to raise further funds for her medical care.So, what is happening behind the scenes at the Achill based religious movement headed up by the slot machine-loving former housewife who has lived in millionaires' mansions while telling followers she gets messages from Jesus and Mary.Nicola speaks with Alan Sherry.
  • Raffaele Imperiale: Mafia Rat (Part 2)

    58:20|
    He is the ultimate Mafia Rat - the narco who found himself cornered and who turned on his own former associates in the cocaine Super Cartel.But who is the Italian who went into business with Daniel Kinahan and who now blames him on his downfall?You are listening to Part 2 of Raffaele Imperiale: Mafia Rat.
  • Raffaele Imperiale: Mafia Rat (Part 1)

    43:15|
    He is the ultimate Mafia Rat - the narco who found himself cornered and who turned on his own former associates in the cocaine Super Cartel.But who is the Italian who went into business with Daniel Kinahan and who now blames him on his downfall?You are listening to Part 1 of Raffaele Imperiale: Mafia Rat.
  • Alexis Campion’s doorstep attack, a gangster’s funeral & Irish couple found dead in Spain

    36:16|
    A court heard this week how Mum of two, Alexis Campion felt like she was in hell after she was set alight on her doorstep in Clondalkin.An Irish businessman told us how he was flown to the UK to organise the funeral of alleged travelling conmen gang member Salis Hanrahan and police ruled out fell play in the tragic case of an Irish woman and her partner found dead in a hot tub in the Spanish holiday villa.Eimear Rabbitt is joined by Neil Fetherstonhaugh as they take a look at some of the biggest stories this week.
  • Solicitor John Finucane refuses to confirm he visited Daniel Kinahan in prison

    17:36|
    Solicitor John Finucane is refusing to confirm that he visited Daniel Kinahan in Portlaoise Prison citing client confidentiality.He is being challenged by opposing politicians who say that he should be forced to confirm or deny his position.Nicola talks to Niall Donald about Kinahan and his legal conundrums.