Share

cover art for The Appin Murder

Crime Time Inc

The Appin Murder

Season 3, Ep. 12

Join us as we delve into the 1752 murder case of Colin Campbell, known as the Red Fox, in the Scottish Highlands. This historical investigation is rife with betrayal, clan rivalry, and lingering speculation. Explore the political tensions of the era, Campbell's ruthless actions, and the controversial trial of James Stewart of the Glens. We discuss various suspects including Alan Breck Stewart, Donald Stewart, and Mungo Campbell, all entangled in a web of mystery that has fascinated historians for centuries. Embrace the enduring intrigue of this famous case and its unanswered questions.


Tom and Simon will discuss this and the rest of this weeks episode's in this Sunday's episode.


00:00 Introduction to the Scottish Highlands Mystery

00:23 Setting the Scene: Political Tensions and Murder

01:06 The Controversial Figure: Colin Campbell

02:06 The Accusation: James Stewart of the Glens

02:29 The Trial: A Questionable Justice

03:11 The Execution: A Grim Warning

04:02 Lingering Questions: Innocence and Whispers

04:29 Introducing Alan Breck Stewart

04:37 The Real Alan Breck Stewart

05:06 Donald Stewart's Alibi

05:34 The Shooting Contest Theory

06:30 Mungo Campbell: A Family Feud

07:39 Concluding Thoughts on the Appin Murder

More episodes

View all episodes

  • 67. The Giselle Pelicot Case

    20:10||Season 3, Ep. 67
    In this episode of Crime Time Inc., we delve into the Giselle Pelicot case, a harrowing story from France that has captured global attention. The case centers on Dominique Pelicot, who convicted of drugging and raping his wife Giselle for over a decade, often involving other men. Giselle courageously waived her anonymity, bringing the case into the public eye and spurring national conversations in France about rape, consent, and systematic failures within the legal system. Dominique’s abusive actions and the involvement of 51 other men, with sentences totaling over 400 years, highlight the disturbing extent of the abuse. The episode explores Dominique's psychological state, potential motivations, and the stark contrast between his outward persona and his heinous acts. Additionally, it sheds light on the larger context of how such abuse can remain hidden, the impact on Giselle and her children, and the broader implications for French society. The case has ignited a movement for legal reform and greater awareness around issues of consent and coercive control. Despite the darkness, Giselle's bravery serves as a beacon of hope and a catalyst for change, emphasizing the importance of speaking out and challenging entrenched cultural norms. The hosts discuss these layers of the case, its ripple effects, and the ongoing quest for justice and systemic reform.00:00 Introduction to the Giselle Pelicot Case00:12 The Horrifying Network of Crimes00:30 Dominique Pelicot's Heinous Acts00:59 Giselle's Courageous Stand01:46 The Trial and Its Impact02:39 Exploring Dominique's Motivations04:35 Giselle's Strength and Public Impact06:34 Legal and Cultural Shifts in France17:55 Global Resonance and Final Thoughts
  • 66. But Aren't They All Evil?

    25:33||Season 3, Ep. 66
    In this episode of Crime Time, Inc., hosts review the second of four Reith lectures from the BBC by forensic psychiatrist, Dr. Gwen Adshead, titled 'But Aren't They All Evil?'. Delivered at the V and A museum in Dundee, Scotland, Dr. Adshead tackles the concept of evil, arguing that everyone has the capacity for it, even if they never act on it. Drawing on her experience with patients in secure psychiatric hospitals and prisons, she challenges the notion that people who commit violent acts are simply 'born evil.' Instead, she discusses various key components that contribute to an 'evil state of mind,' such as cognitive distortions, hyper individualism, a sense of entitlement, and self-deception. The hosts discuss how societal narratives and personal histories influence violent behavior, touching on notable examples like the Holocaust. Audience members in the Q&A contribute personal stories and challenge Dr. Adshead's views on the inherent nature of evil. The conversation transitions to the role of emotions, societal influences, and educational programs in preventing violence. Throughout, Dr. Adshead advocates for a nuanced understanding of human behavior and suggests that cultivating compassion and gratitude can counteract negative forces. The episode ends with a teaser for Dr. Adshead's next lecture, focused on the impact of childhood trauma on violence, which will be delivered from Grendon Prison in England.00:00 Introduction to Dr. Gwen Adshead's Lecture00:38 Challenging the Concept of Evil03:15 Components of an Evil State of Mind06:47 The Role of Emotions and Societal Influences08:18 Audience Reactions and Q&A12:47 Distorted Narratives and Self-Justification13:30 Violence as an Addiction14:21 The Role of Education in Reducing Violence15:44 The Age of Rage: Societal Anger and Accountability16:52 Gendered Aspects of Anger and Violence17:50 Public Health Approach to Violence Prevention18:34 Victims' Perspectives on Violence20:37 Religion and Rehabilitation22:35 Concluding Thoughts and Future Lectures
  • 65. They Tried to Kill Margaret Thatcher

    15:37||Season 3, Ep. 65
    In this episode of Crime Time, Inc., we delve into the harrowing events of the 1984 Brighton Hotel bombing. The episode begins by setting the political backdrop of The Troubles in Northern Ireland, detailing the complex conflict between unionists and republicans. The narrative then focuses on the bombing itself, aimed at the British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher, who narrowly escaped. The meticulous planning carried out by IRA operative Patrick McGee is examined, along with the devastating impact of the blast, which killed five people and injured thirty-four others. The episode also highlights the subsequent investigation that led to McGee's capture and conviction. Moving beyond the immediate aftermath, the discussion explores the heightened security measures implemented in Britain and the ongoing debates about the balance between security and civil liberties. A poignant segment of the episode narrates the remarkable story of reconciliation between Joe Barry, daughter of one of the victims, and Patrick McGee, symbolizing the potential for forgiveness and understanding in the quest for peace. Through in-depth analysis and emotional storytelling, this episode provides valuable insights into the complexities of political violence, the human cost of conflict, and the enduring hope for a future free from violence.00:00 Introduction to the Brighton Hotel Bombing00:15 Understanding The Troubles01:03 The IRA and the Attack on Margaret Thatcher02:36 Details of the Brighton Hotel Bombing04:00 The Human Cost and Immediate Aftermath05:24 Investigation and Arrest of Patrick McGee06:14 Trial and Sentencing of Patrick McGee06:39 Impact on British Society and Security07:22 The Good Friday Agreement and McGee's Release08:12 Joe Barry's Remarkable Journey Towards Forgiveness13:14 Final Reflections and Security Changes14:55 Conclusion and Upcoming Episodes
  • 64. Mastering Online Security Basics

    21:05||Season 3, Ep. 64
    with Crime Time Inc.Welcome back to Crime Time Inc. In this episode, we delve deep into the essentials of online security with an expert who shares crucial tips and strategies to protect yourself in the digital world. The discussion begins with the importance of strong, unique passwords and how a password manager can simplify the task of maintaining them. We then explore two-factor authentication as an additional layer of security. The focus shifts to the significance of using separate email addresses for sensitive accounts, and even dedicating a specific device solely for financial transactions to reduce malware risks. Learn about the benefits of tap-to-pay and virtual credit cards in securing online payments and protecting your credit card information. The conversation further covers essential phone security measures, including stolen device protection and careful management of app permissions. We also demystify online tracking, explaining cookies, and how to manage them by blocking third-party cookies and clearing them regularly. Discover privacy-focused browsers like Brave and the benefits of using VPNs for data encryption and protection. The discussion rounds off with minimizing online exposure by being cautious about the information you share and the permissions you grant, as well as the importance of regular data backups. This episode is packed with practical advice aimed at building a strong, proactive security posture to keep you safe online.00:00 Introduction to Online Security00:35 The Importance of Strong Passwords01:22 Password Managers and Two-Factor Authentication02:47 Securing Your Email and Devices04:08 Safe Online Payments05:14 Phone Security Tips06:05 Understanding Cookies and Online Tracking09:05 Using Privacy-Focused Browsers10:12 The Role of VPNs in Online Security11:30 Minimizing Online Exposure15:01 The Importance of Backups17:53 Final Thoughts on Online Security
  • 63. Deep Dive into Unsolved Crimes: From Ned Kelly to JonBenét Ramsey

    51:00||Season 3, Ep. 63
    Tom and Simon kick off with a discussion about Simon's upcoming trip to Australia for Crime Time Inc., emphasizing the importance of exemplary conduct and noting the organization's tight expense policies. They delve into famous Australian cases, including the legendary outlaw Ned Kelly. The conversation then shifts to a series of topical crimes, particularly those around Christmas time, as noted by their deep dive team. Paul Logan's unsolved murder is highlighted, with Tom discussing the importance of preserving evidence and keeping cold cases 'warm' for potential breakthroughs. They touch on infamous cases like the Sodder children and JonBenét Ramsey, critiquing poor initial crime scene management and exploring potential theories behind the incidents. The pair also reflect on Amelia Earhart's mysterious disappearance and the influence of conspiracy theories, driven by social media. The podcast transitions to a broader analysis of crime scene investigations, the importance of immediate actions by first responders, and conspiracy theories' propensity to thrive in the absence of definitive answers. Notably, Tom praises Police Scotland's Homicide Review Board for their methodical and thorough approach to solving cold cases. The episode also teases a future live show at the Mitchell Library in Glasgow and mentions their special guest, former crime reporter Jane Hamilton, who will bring a unique perspective as a journalist. This episode offers a blend of case analysis, procedural critique, and personal anecdotes, providing listeners with insight into the investigative process and the challenges faced in high-profile crime inquiries.00:00 Introduction and Trip Preparations00:21 Professional Conduct and Expense Warnings01:40 Famous Australian Cases01:57 Christmas Crimes and Cold Cases04:44 The Paul Logan Case06:56 Cold Case Investigations11:50 Forensic Evidence and Lockhart's Exchange Theory16:53 The Sodder Children Disappearance23:06 Violence in Policing26:11 The Importance of Searching Prisoners27:36 Public Inquiry into Sheku Bayoh's Death29:49 Botched Crime Scenes: Jon Benét Ramsey Case35:57 The Maurin Murders: A Complex Case42:20 Amelia Earhart: The Mystery of Her Disappearance46:16 Conspiracy Theories and Social Media48:57 Upcoming Live Show Details
  • 62. Unravelling the Amelia Earhart Mystery

    13:34||Season 3, Ep. 62
    In this episode of Crimetime Inc., we delve deep into the enduring mystery of Amelia Earhart's disappearance. Amelia Earhart, the pioneering aviator, vanished over the Pacific Ocean in 1937 while attempting a groundbreaking round-the-world flight with her navigator Fred Noonan. We explore the rich trove of information surrounding her final flight, the planned navigation methods, and the ensuing frantic search efforts that have left us with more questions than answers. Our discussion covers Earhart's last known flight on July 2, 1937, from Ley Airfield in New Guinea to Howland Island, and the technological challenges they faced with navigation and communication. We analyze the official U.S. government theory that the duo ran out of fuel and crashed into the ocean, as well as the Gardner Island Hypothesis, suggesting they may have landed on Nikumaroro Island. Additionally, we scrutinize the controversial Commander Thompson theory that hints at mishandled search efforts, and even touch on conspiracy theories that Earhart was on a secret U.S. mission and captured by the Japanese, or staged her own disappearance to escape fame. Despite a massive search operation and numerous expeditions over the years, no conclusive evidence has been found. Join us as we piece together various facts, theories, and details in an attempt to shed light on this decades-old enigma and reflect on Earhart's enduring legacy as a beacon of courage and inspiration in aviation.00:00 Introduction to Amelia Earhart's Mystery00:46 The Final Flight: July 2nd, 193701:15 Technological Challenges and Communication Issues03:11 The Disappearance and Initial Search Efforts05:02 Theories and Speculations06:44 Controversies and Conspiracies09:17 The Enduring Fascination and Legacy12:42 Conclusion and Reflections
  • 61. The 1985 Murders That Shook Ethel: A Decades-Long Pursuit of Justice

    12:17||Season 3, Ep. 61
    In this episode of Crime Time, Inc., we delve into the chilling 1985 murders of Ed and Minnie Maurin in the small town of Ethel. This case highlights the complexities and twists of a seemingly simple crime that spiraled into a decades-long search for truth. From the initial mysterious disappearance, the shocking discovery of their bodies on Christmas Eve, to false leads and a renewed investigation that culminated in an arrest decades later, this episode explores how fear, silence, and determination played pivotal roles in the pursuit of justice.00:00 Introduction to the 1985 Maurin Murders01:03 The Discovery of the Crime Scene02:03 Initial Theories and Dead Ends04:06 A Son's Relentless Pursuit of Justice04:38 False Leads and Sting Operations06:22 A New Lead Emerges08:24 The Riff Brothers and the Alaska Connection09:50 The Trial and Verdict11:26 Reflections on Justice and Closure
  • 60. Unraveling the JonBenét Ramsey Mystery: 28 Years Later

    29:19||Season 3, Ep. 60
    In this episode of Crimetime Inc., we take a deep dive into the perplexing case of JonBenet Ramsey, 28 years after her untimely death. The discussion covers a wide array of sources including podcast excerpts, case studies, news articles, and more. We examine key facts, evidence, and the most prominent theories surrounding the case. From the bizarre ransom note and the missteps in the early investigation, to the unsettling suspects and the enduring media frenzy, we explore all facets of this enduring mystery. Despite advances in forensic science and countless efforts, the truth about JonBenet's death remains elusive, stirring public imagination and debate to this day.00:00 Introduction to the JonBenet Ramsey Case00:44 The Night of the Incident01:10 The Ransom Note Discovery01:59 Initial Police Response and Mistakes03:27 The Devastating Discovery06:08 Media Frenzy and Public Scrutiny09:48 Family Involvement Theories10:58 Intruder Theory and DNA Evidence13:31 Other Potential Suspects14:36 Suspects Under Scrutiny17:05 The Media's Role in the Investigation19:17 Intriguing Evidence and Theories26:15 Lasting Implications and Key Takeaways
  • 59. Understanding Violence

    16:16||Season 3, Ep. 59
    Understanding Violence: Dr. Gwen Adshead's First Reith LectureIn this episode of Crime Time, Inc., we delve into the first of four Reith Lectures by Forensic Psychiatrist Dr. Gwen Adshead. Titled 'Is Violence Normal?' this lecture explores the complexities surrounding human violence. Dr. Adshead, who has extensive experience working in prisons and high-security hospitals like Broadmoor, argues that violence is a part of human nature and is influenced by various social and individual factors. She challenges the conventional notion of profiling typical killers and urges us to understand the relational contexts and risk factors that lead to violence. Using the analogy of a bicycle lock, she explains how different risk factors combine to unlock violent behaviour. Dr. Adshead highlights the importance of responsibility and the dangers of normalising violence through media and societal narratives. The discussion also touches on the role of mental illness, the potential for rehabilitation, and the need for nuanced approaches to preventing violence. Tune in for a thought-provoking episode that pushes us to reconsider our assumptions about violence and its perpetrators.00:00 Introduction to the Reith Lectures00:42 Overview of Dr. Gwen Adshead's Lectures00:54 Is Violence Normal?01:40 Understanding the Roots of Violence03:30 The Bicycle Lock Analogy04:28 Neutralization and Responsibility06:19 Challenging the Concept of Evil13:41 Rehabilitation and Change15:24 Final Thoughts and Takeaways