Share

Crime Salad +
Vanished in NYC: The Mysterious Case of Joseph Comunale
•
In this episode, we will discuss the tragic case of Joseph Comunale. A 26-year-old man from Stamford, Connecticut, whose night of revelry in New York City turned into a horrifying nightmare. On November 13, 2016, Joseph traveled to the Big Apple for what he hoped would be a fun and memorable evening. However, the night took a sinister turn during a party where heavy drinking and possible drug use set the stage and then, sadly, a violent altercation. By Monday, Joseph Comunale was reported missing, and what unfolded was a devastating story of a young life cut short. Join us as we uncover the chilling details of this heart-wrenching case and explore the fateful events that led to his untimely death.
More episodes
View all episodes
Weird History (Bonus): The Town That Danced Itself to Death
12:16|In the summer of 1518, the people of Strasbourg started dancing… and just didn’t stop. No, seriously—they danced for days, some even to their deaths. Was it a curse? A case of mass hysteria? Or just some really bad moldy bread?In this fun bonus episode, Ashley and Ricky are taking a little break from true crime to bring you something weird from history. Don’t worry—our regular weekly crime episodes aren’t going anywhere. We just love strange stories and history… and we love you.Thanks for listening and keeping things crunchy!Disappeared: Amber Dubois and Chelsea King
23:19|Content Warning: This episode contains detailed discussion of child abduction, sexual violence, and murder. Listener discretion is advised.In February 2009, 14-year-old Amber Dubois disappeared while walking to school in Escondido, California. Her family searched tirelessly—without answers. A year later, 17-year-old Chelsea King went missing during her routine run in a nearby park.Was this a total coincidence that two young girls completely vanished? Or was there a serial killer to blame? In this episode, we piece together the facts behind Amber’s disappearance, the shocking investigation into serial offender John Gardner, and how one mother’s heartbreak became a mission to protect others.Hosted by Ashley and Ricky Plum of Crime Salad. Episode Resources & Support LinksIf you'd like to support the families affected by today’s case or learn more:Amber Dubois Memorial Foundation https://www.amberduboisfoundation.orgChelsea’s Light Foundation https://www.chelseaslight.orgIf you or someone you know has been impacted by a case like this, here are some organizations offering grief support and victim advocacy:National Center for Victims of Crime https://victimsofcrime.orgParents of Murdered Children (POMC) https://pomc.orgRAINN (Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network) https://www.rainn.org | 24/7 Hotline: 1-800-656-HOPEThe Dougy Center—Grief Support for Children & Families https://www.dougy.orgCrisis Text Line Text HOME to 741741 (free, 24/7 crisis support)Have a Case You Want Us to Cover?If there's a case you'd like to hear us cover, please reach out—we’re always listening!Follow us on our most active platforms: TikTok Instagram Facebook (we check it too, just not as often)Murder Without Justice: Jason Corbett
36:47|When Irish father Jason Corbett relocated to North Carolina with his two children, it was meant to be a fresh chapter after the tragic loss of his first wife, Mags. He eventually married Molly Martens, an American woman hired to help care for his young children. But nearly a decade later, Jason’s life would end violently inside their North Carolina home—sparking an international investigation and a courtroom battle that has left many questions unanswered.In this episode, we look deeper into the years leading up to Jason’s death through the eyes of his daughter Sarah, now an adult, and his sister Tracey Corbett Lynch, who has long fought for answers. Tracey remembers troubling signs during the couple’s wedding visit to America, including Molly’s alleged behavior and inconsistencies in her personal story. Meanwhile, Sarah later came forward with unsettling memories from childhood—claims that challenge the public image of a loving stepmother and raise questions about control and manipulation inside the home.From conflicting narratives to transatlantic legal twists, we break down the facts, examine the claims, and explore why many still feel justice remains out of reach for Jason Corbett and his children.Please note: This episode contains discussions of domestic violence, mental health, and graphic content related to a violent murder. Listener discretion is advised.The Zoo Man: The Thomas Huskey Case
27:12|In the 1990s, Knoxville’s ‘Zoo Man’ wasn’t just caring for elephants—he was hiding horrific secrets. Thomas Huskey was accused of attacking sex workers and eventually linked to multiple murders. His shocking defense? Multiple personalities. This is the disturbing true story of the Zoo Man Killer.Content Warning: sexual assault, sex work, strangulation, murder, and mental illness.Need support? • UK: NUM – Call 0800 464 7669 (Tues–Fri, 10am–4pm) or email casework@nationaluglymugs.org • US: Sex Workers Project – Call 646-602-5617 or email swp@urbanjustice.orgThomas HuskeyZoo Man KillerKnoxville murdersKnoxville ZooMagnolia Avenue KnoxvilleTennessee serial killerDissociative Identity DisorderDID defense1990s true crimeserial killer podcastsex worker homicidesunsolved true crimetrue crime podcast🔎 #TrueCrime #ZooMan #ThomasHuskey #SerialKiller #KnoxvilleTrueCrime #DID #MentalHealth #CrimePodcast #Unsolved #MurderMysteryThe Death of Stephanie Wasilishin: A Mystery Still Unsolved
40:20|In this episode of Crime Salad, we’re diving into the heartbreaking story of Stephanie Marie Wasilishin—a devoted mother, talented pastry chef, and vibrant woman whose life was cut short on July 9, 1993. What happened that night in Sedona, Arizona has haunted her family for over three decades, especially her daughters, Nikki and Christina.Stephanie’s story began long before that tragic night. After the loss of her twin brother in infancy, her family relocated from Illinois to the Deep South, settling in Arizona. Years later, she would meet Russell Peterson, the man who would become her partner and the father of her youngest daughter. But when Stephanie was found dead in their home, and Russell was the only witness, the lines between accident, suicide, and murder became painfully blurred.Despite Stephanie’s death being ruled a homicide, no one has ever been charged—and the case remains one of the many unsolved mysteries we explore on this show. Through Nikki’s courageous efforts to seek justice and keep her mother’s story alive!If you’re drawn to true crime stories that mix deep emotion with disturbing questions, this one’s for you. We’re unpacking not only a potential murder, but the ripple effect it left behind.Be sure to follow us on social media for updates, contemporary crimes, behind-the-scenes content, and more: 📱 TikTok, Instagram, Facebook → @crimesaladpodcastWhile you're there, follow Stephanie’s daughter on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@nicolewasilishinAlso, please consider signing this petition: https://www.change.org/p/demand-a-complete-homicide-investigation-for-the-murder-of-stephanie-marie-wasilishin?source_location=petition_update_pageAs always, we’re so grateful for our Crime Salad Patreon and Apple subscribers—your support means the world to us and helps us play our part in spreading awareness about these important topics.Gone Too Soon: Dylan Rounds’ Fight for Justice
16:22|On May 28, 2022, 19-year-old Dylan Rounds vanished in the Utah desert—his life and dreams of building something of his own were cut short by senseless violence. In today’s episode, we reflect on the impact of Dylan’s story, where the case stands today, and how his loved ones continue to fight.Want to help or learn more? Visit dylanroundslegacy.org.Please consider sharing this episode on social media to help keep Dylan’s story alive.We’re incredibly thankful for our Crime Salad Patreon and Apple subscribers—your support helps us continue telling the stories that matter.Support here: patreon.com/CrimesaladpodcastSide Salad: 18-year-old escaped: The Gloucester Township Horror Story
13:23|On May 8, 2025, a teenage girl arrived at A Wawa convenience store in Gloucester Township, New Jersey. Her shaved head and scarred-up wrists clearly told a story that something was wrong. She wasn’t there to grab a snack or fill up a gas tank—her neighbor had driven her there to meet authorities. She was in desperation to escape a nightmare that, according to investigators, had lasted nearly seven long years. But in the moment she was hesitant to tell them everything. Her story would later reveal years of abuse and imprisonment—suffering inflicted by the very people who were supposed to love and protect her. Somehow, it all went unnoticed, hidden behind closed doors with no contact with the outside world. What makes this case even more disturbing is how it exposes the glaring gaps in how we monitor the safety and well-being of homeschooled children in America.Listener discretion is strongly advised. If you or someone you know is experiencing abuse or needs help, contact the National Child Abuse Hotline at 1-800-4-A-CHILD (1-800-422-4453) or visit childhelp.org for resources and support.The Hoax of Anthony Godby Johnson
40:06|By the time he was just 14 years old, Anthony Godby Johnson had already captured the hearts of celebrities, journalists, and readers across the country. His memoir, A Rock and a Hard Place: One Boy’s Triumphant Story, detailed an unthinkable past—years of abuse, abandonment, and a devastating AIDS diagnosis, which grabbed the hearts of so many! In this episode, we dive into the possible hoax that rocked the literary world. We will explore how AIDS awareness, child abuse, and internet-era deception collided—while challenging the ultimate question: who was really behind Anthony Godby Johnson?Thanks for supporting Crime Salad! Please subscribe to our show and tell a friend about your favorite salad...Do you follow us?! If not, please do!!Instagram: @crimesaladpodcastTikTok: @crimesaladpodcastFacebook: Crime Salad PodcastUnsolved: Amy Mihaljevic Throwback Episode
46:33|In this special throwback episode, we revisit the haunting unsolved case of Amy Mihaljevic, the 10-year-old girl who was abducted from a Bay Village, Ohio shopping plaza in 1989 and later found murdered in a rural Ashland County field. We’ll take you through the chilling timeline, exploring the ongoing investigation, new DNA testing, and the relentless pursuit of answers that still grips investigators and true crime enthusiasts alike. With fresh updates and expert insights, we ask, will Amy’s killer finally be brought to justice? Despite the passage of 35 years, hope remains alive, and the truth is still waiting to be uncovered.Thanks fo supporting Crime Salad!!