Share

cover art for The Murder of Jennifer Daugherty (The Greensburg Six Case)

Crime Salad +

The Murder of Jennifer Daugherty (The Greensburg Six Case)

On a snowy morning in Greensburg, Pennsylvania, a school worker made a puzzling discovery outside Greensburg Salem Middle School—a heavy garbage can lodged beneath his truck. What he found inside would unravel one of the most shocking cases in Westmoreland County history.

In this episode of Crime Salad, we uncover the disturbing story of Jennifer Daugherty and the horrifying secrets that shook a quiet Pennsylvania town.

More episodes

View all episodes

  • "She'd Go Ballistic" | The Suspicious Death of David Elmquist

    01:05:48|
    ⚠️ Listener Discretion is Advised: The following episode contains intense and explicit descriptions of domestic violence, suicide, and a highly traumatic death involving fire. The information presented is based on publicly available records, family statements, and alleged accounts. This podcast is for informational purposes only. We are not law enforcement, legal professionals, or medical experts, and we are not accusing anyone of any crimes.On February 8, 2018, in the freezing cold of Plymouth, Minnesota, 24-year-old David Elmquist was burning alive inside his apartment. His death was ruled a suicide before he was even officially pronounced dead. But for the last six years, his family has fought tirelessly to prove that the official story doesn't add up.With reports of perfectly unburned wrists on a body covered in severe burns, a pristine knife found in a soot-filled room, shifting timelines, and a tragic 38-minute standoff where police waited outside the burning apartment, the physical evidence points to something much darker. Furthermore, just hours before his death, David confided in his parents that he was planning to leave his wife, warning them that if he told her, "she'd go ballistic."In this episode, we unpack the glaring inconsistencies, the alleged forensic bias, the mental health stigma that clouded the investigation, and a father’s relentless fight for justice.Call to Action & Resources:Listen to The Stacked Deck Podcast: Hear the six-part series directly from David’s father, Scott, detailing the entire case. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-stacked-deck/id1767907803Support the Family: Follow the Truth and Justice for David Elmquist Facebook page and sign the petition demanding an independent prosecutor. Sign the PetitionSupport Crime Salad:Merch: Grab your gear at https://crimesaladpodcast.dashery.com/
  • What Happened to Anna Kepner on the Carnival Horizon?

    52:06|
    In November 2025, 18-year-old Anna Kepner boarded the Carnival Horizon cruise ship with her family for a six-night Caribbean vacation. On the final sea day, she was found dead, hidden under her bed inside her own cabin. Surveillance footage reportedly showed only one person entering and leaving the stateroom during that window: her 16-year-old stepbrother.The FBI took over the investigation, and federal homicide charges were eventually filed against the minor suspect. But as the legal process unfolded, court filings, leaked messages, and accusations from family members revealed a much more complicated picture of what was happening inside that household long before anyone boarded that ship.In this episode, Ashley and Ricky break down the full timeline of Anna Kepner's case. The family cruise, the discovery, the cause of death, the suspect's mental health history and missed medication, the explosive custody battle between the parents, the social media firestorm, and the questions that still have no answers.Anna was a diver, a cheerleader, a Georgia Bulldogs fan, and an aspiring Navy recruit and K-9 officer from Titusville, Florida. She was 18 years old with her whole life ahead of her. She deserves to be remembered for who she was.Content Warning: This episode discusses violence, domestic abuse, and the death of a young person.If you have information related to this case, contact the FBI Miami Field Office or submit a tip at tips.fbi.gov
  • The Disappearance of Holly Bobo: Taken in Broad Daylight

    27:46|
    HEEEYYY this is a THROWBACK for y'all. We have updates at the end!! Recorded this one 5 years ago; please understand we were trying our best LOL and trying to figure out podcasting. It's cool to hear.It's a busy week, and it seems like a good week for some leftover crime salad. ha. ha. ha. The sun is shining!!! Enjoy your weekend. We are working on a fresh episode coming out next week.<3 Ashley and Ricky.On the morning of April 13, 2011, nursing student Holly Bobo was abducted from her family's home in Darden, Tennessee, while her brother watched from inside the house, believing she was walking with her boyfriend. What followed was a three-and-a-half-year search that gripped a small town and drew national attention. When arrests finally came, so did shocking confessions, but allegations of coerced statements, fabricated evidence, and prosecutorial misconduct have left many wondering: was justice truly served? Ashley and Ricky break down the case, the controversial trial, and the lingering questions that remain.
  • The Disappearance of Celeste Doghmi: Missing for 2 Years in Auburn, Maine

    35:36|
    In the summer of 2021, in the quiet river city of Auburn, Maine, 27-year-old Celeste Doghmi was at a turning point. After years of struggle and addiction, Celeste had completely turned her life around. She was a devoted new mother, had purchased her first-semester nursing textbooks, and was sharing her pride and love for her infant son on social media every day.But following a harrowing final video call with a close friend, one that captured a violent domestic dispute, Celeste's digital and physical footprint vanished.In this episode of Crime Salad, Ashley and Ricky dive into one of the most unsettling missing persons cases in recent Maine history. We explore the legal reality of being classified as a "voluntary missing adult," the dark mechanics of coercive control and isolation, and the systemic failures that allowed a young mother to go unreported for nearly two years before authorities were even alerted.Was it a voluntary exit, or was the home life described by investigators as a "war zone" a precursor to something far more sinister? We examine her partner's criminal history, the ongoing investigation by the Maine State Police Major Crimes Unit, and the tireless fight by Celeste's mother, Stephanie, to find justice for her daughter and her grandson.Celeste Doghmi, domestic violence, missing person, Auburn Maine, cold case, coercive control, Maine State Police, unsolved, true crime, parental custody, Crime Salad podcastIf you have any information regarding the disappearance of Celeste Doghmi, please contact the Maine State Police tip line or the Auburn Police Department at 207-333-6653National Domestic Violence Hotline: 1-800-799-7233 Text START to 88788. You are not alone. https://www.thehotline.org/Merch & Show Info: crimesaladpodcast.com
  • The Disappearance of Lonene Rogers

    44:54|
    This episode contains content related to domestic violence, child neglect, and homicide. Listener discretion is advised.If you or someone you know is experiencing domestic abuse, help is available around the clock through the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233 or by texting START to 88788. You are not alone.On the night of January 6th, 1981, Lonene Rogers finished her work shift, picked up her two young children from the babysitter, and came home to an argument with her estranged husband. By morning, she was gone. No footprints in the snow. No activity on her Social Security number. Her hearing aids, glasses, purse, and car were all still there.Lonene was a profoundly deaf woman from northwestern Pennsylvania who refused to let her disability define her. She was strong-willed and warm, a devoted mother, and by early 1981, she was finally ready to leave a troubled marriage and build a new life. Instead, she vanished in the middle of a blizzard and was never seen again.For 44 years, her disappearance went unsolved. Her parents died without answers. Her children grew up without her. And her husband, Clinton "Bud" Rogers, maintained the same story: he woke up and she was simply gone.In this episode, we trace Lonene's life from her childhood in Youngstown, Ohio, through the marriage that her own family saw warning signs in from the start to the night she disappeared and the search that turned up nothing. We also follow her daughter Alison, who spent decades trying to distance herself from the tragedy before deciding, in 2021, to dedicate herself to finding the truth. Alison's fight took her through court battles, advocacy for a proposed new law called Lonnie's Law, and years of pressure on investigators and the public alike.In November 2025, that fight finally produced a result. After more than four decades of silence, Bud Rogers confessed.This is Lonene's story, and it is also the story of a daughter who refused to let her mother be forgotten.Content warning: This episode contains descriptions of domestic violence, child neglect, and a murder confession.If you are in the northwestern Pennsylvania area, Lonene's family invites you to join a peaceful gathering outside the Crawford County Courthouse at 903 Diamond Park Square in Meadville, PA, on Monday, March 30, 2026, from 9 to 11 am. A hearing in her case will be taking place inside the courthouse that morning, and the community is gathering outside in her memory and in solidarity with victims of domestic violence and the missing and murdered.She will never stand alone again. 💜National Domestic Violence Hotline: 1-800-799-7233Text START to 88788. You are not alone. https://www.thehotline.org/Justice for Lonene Rogers Facebook Page: https://www.facebook.com/groups/285829136570490/  Sign the petition for Lonnie’s Law: https://c.org/mMwHNqtRGCAlison's book, "A Daughter's Journey and Story of Resilience," is available on Amazon: https://a.co/d/0gWrklLESupport Crime Salad: Merch
  • Sara Easton: Suicide or Homicide? The Suspicious Death of a Yuba City Mother

    51:00|
    On August 16, 2015, Sara Easton, a 31-year-old mother of three from Yuba City, California, died from a gunshot wound in her bedroom. Investigators quickly moved toward a suicide ruling. Her family never accepted it.Sara's husband was Aaron Easton, then-Chief of the Marysville Police Department. And the more forensic details emerged, including the autopsy findings, the toxicology results, the witness accounts, and the history of alleged domestic abuse, the more questions piled up around a case that many believe was never properly investigated.Was this a suicide? A homicide? And did Aaron Easton's position in law enforcement shape the way this case was handled?In this episode, Ashley and Ricky break down the full timeline of Sara's death, examine the forensic and autopsy evidence, explore the conflicts of interest that shadowed the investigation, and look at the later allegations against Aaron Easton that have kept this case under scrutiny for nearly a decade.Sara's family is still pushing for answers. This is their story, and hers.This episode covers: suspicious death investigation · forensic evidence · suicide vs. homicide · domestic violence allegations · law enforcement conflicts of interest · unsolved cases · police accountabilitySupport Crime Salad: MerchAd-Free Listens: PatreonSponsors for the show: Miracle Made: Upgrade your sleep with Miracle Made! Go to https://trymiracle.com/CRIMESALAD and use code CRIMESALAD to claim your FREE 3 PIECE TOWEL SET and SAVE over 40% OFFRula: Rula patients typically pay $15 per session when using insurance. Connect with quality therapists at https://www.rula.com/salad #rulapod
  • Na’Ziyah Harris | The Detroit Teen Who Disappeared After School

    50:18|
    In this episode of Crime Salad, Ashley and Ricky examine the case of Na’Ziyah Harris, a 13-year-old girl from Detroit, Michigan, who disappeared after getting off her school bus on January 9, 2024, near Cornwall Street and Three Mile Drive on Detroit’s east side. What began as a missing child investigation quickly turned into something far more disturbing as detectives uncovered digital messages, witness testimony, and evidence pointing to a hidden relationship that had been unfolding for years.Listener discretion is advised.Keywords:Na’Ziyah Harris, Detroit Michigan, Detroit missing child case, Jarvis Butts, Detroit Police Department, Wayne County Michigan, Seven Mile Road Detroit, Rouge River Detroit, true crime podcast, Crime Salad, red flag relationships, child predator signs
  • Confidential and Dangerous: The Andrew Sadek Case

    58:13|
    Andrew Sadek was a 20-year-old college student at North Dakota State College of Science when he disappeared from his dorm in Wahpeton, North Dakota. Weeks later, his body was found in the Red River. His death was ruled a suicide, but the circumstances surrounding it have continued to raise questions.In this episode of Crime Salad, we examine Andrew’s case and the broader risks tied to confidential informant agreements, including the pressures placed on young or first-time offenders and the lack of consistent oversight and safety.For Andrew’s parents, the fight has been endless. Was enough done to protect him? Who should be held accountable?
  • The Katie Autry Case: The Dorm Room Attack at WKU

    53:02|
    *Listener discretion is advised. This episode contains discussion of sexual violence, severe physical injury, and death.In the early morning hours of May 2003, a piercing fire alarm shattered the silence inside Hugh Poland Hall at Western Kentucky University. Students poured out into the dark, confused and half-asleep, unaware that behind one closed dorm room door an 18-year-old freshman was fighting for her life. This episode of Crime Salad examines the brutal attack on Katie Autry, a case that shocked the WKU campus, raised questions about campus safety, and continues to spark debate more than two decades later.Ashley and Ricky break down the timeline, the investigation, courtroom developments, and the lingering controversies surrounding one of the most disturbing true crime cases in Bowling Green, Kentucky. From the initial emergency response inside Room 214 to the legal aftermath and public reaction, this episode explores how a night meant to be ordinary turned into a tragedy that still resonates with students, families, and true crime followers today.Keywords: Katie Autry case, Western Kentucky University true crime, WKU dorm fire 2003, Bowling Green Kentucky crime, campus crime podcast, Crime Salad podcast, college campus safety, unsolved questions, true crime investigation, dorm room attack.