Share

cover art for Why liberalism is worth saving

Crikey's Electioncast - a daily Australian federal election podcast

Why liberalism is worth saving

•

With the fragmentation and loss of belief in the Liberal Party, the future of liberalism itself these days doesn’t look bright. But what would a “post-liberal” world look like?


This week on Cut Through, Tim Dean, resident philosopher at The Ethics Centre, joins Rachel Withers to talk about why liberalism is worth fighting for despite its flaws, and the ways that the left and the right can join together to fight disillusion, division and dismay. Plus, the moral erosion of the Trump administration’s short-lived promise of a livestreamed execution.


Today’s episode covers:

  • The threats to liberalism
  • What are the problems with liberalism today?
  • What should the left be doing differently?
  • What should the right be doing differently?
  • The perversions of neoliberalism
  • The immorality of public executions
  • What does public execution signal to a population?
  • How technology disseminates violence


Read the transcript here, watch or listen to the episode above.

Want to ask us a question? Send an email to letters@crikey.com.au or contact us using the secure methods detailed here.


Read more:

The only thing worse than liberalism is everything else

What’s wrong with public executions?


Want to ask us a question? Send an email to letters@crikey.com.au or contact us using the secure methods detailed here: https://www.crikey.com.au/tip-off-crikey/


Subscribe to Crikey now to get 60% off your annual subscription!

Sign up to Crikey’s free newsletter: https://bit.ly/crikey-newsletter


Crikey’s independent journalism is supported by readers — 98% of our revenue comes from our subscribers. We’re not accountable to billionaires; we’re accountable to you.

More episodes

View all episodes

  • Is it time to ditch Albo?

    41:03|
    Welcome to Crikey’s inaugural debate podcast, Uppercut, where we drag a couple of heavyweights into the ring to battle it out on the issue of the day. Today’s question: With Anthony Albanese slipping in the polls, going from gaffe to gaffe and seemingly disliked by voters to both the left and right of him, is it time for Labor and the country to look elsewhere?Politics reporter Bernard Keane argues that while he’s no fan of Albo, Labor lacks the talent to change its leader at this stage of the electoral cycle. Rachel Withers, however, feels as though almost anyone in the Labor cabinet would be better than the PM at this point. Is Bernard a Liberal Party operative? Could Andrew Hastie be leader of the Labor Party? Will Charlie keep pronouncing it “Al-buh-nay-zay”? Tune in to find out. Today’s episode covers:Why we’re asking this question Round 1: Does Albanese believe in anything anymore? Albanese’s electioneering strength (and Labor’s lack of talent) Labor’s policy ambition has gone missing Round 2: How the Rudd/Gillard years affected how leaders are changed Does Labor need an outsider? Round 3: Who else could be Labor leader?Bernard <3 Andrew Hastie Read the transcript here, watch or listen to the episode above.Want to ask us a question? Send an email to letters@crikey.com.au or contact us using the secure methods detailed here.Subscribe to Crikey now to get 70% off your annual subscription!
  • Who are the new One Nation voters?

    29:38|
    Pauline Hanson’s One Nation has gone from the fringes of political relevance to a genuine challenger at both state and federal level. As the party’s polling reaches heights of up to 30%, we wanted to find out who these new voters are, and why they had abandoned the two major parties.Journalist Michael Sainsbury joins Rachel Withers to discuss his recent conversations with One Nation converts, what they’re hoping the party can do for them, and how they are able to stomach some of Pauline Hanson’s more extreme positions.Today’s episode covers:Conversations with One Nation’s newest votersSimilarities between One Nation and MAGAVoters abandoning their traditional partiesAre One Nation voters just ignoring the racism?Can One Nation actually govern?How journalists should be reporting on One Nation and its supportersAddressing factual inaccuracies in a “post-truth” worldWhere will voters go if One Nation implodes?Read the transcript here, watch or listen to the episode above.Want to ask us a question? Send an email to letters@crikey.com.au or contact us using the secure methods detailed here.READ MORE:‘I didn’t change. Labor did’: Meet the voters One Nation is stealing from the major partiesWant to ask us a question? Send an email to letters@crikey.com.au or contact us using the secure methods detailed here: https://www.crikey.com.au/tip-off-crikey/Subscribe to Crikey now to get 50% off your annual subscription! https://campaigns.crikey.com.au/subscribe
  • Inside the Herzog protest inquiry police wanted kept secret

    30:00|
    After a protest in Sydney against a visit from Israeli President Isaac Herzog, social media was flooded with videos of police pushing, punching and pepper-spraying protesters. Months later, those same protesters are still waiting for answers from NSW Police as the force is subject to an investigation by the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission.Charlie Lewis speaks to Tina Quinn about her interviews with those protesters, how the police tried to prevent some evidence from going public, and what this means for the future of protest policing in NSW and across Australia.Today’s episode covers:Recap: What happened at the Isaac Herzog protestHow the NSW Police commissioner tried to limit scrutinyThe ‘draconian’ crackdown on protest in AustraliaStories from the protestersHannah Thomas: “It felt like they were at war with us”Will the “Permanent Armed Response” team be used at demonstrations?What’s next for the protesters and the commission?Read the transcript here, watch or listen to the episode above.READ MORE:"Has changed my life irrevocably": The Herzog protesters are still waiting for answersWant to ask us a question? Send an email to letters@crikey.com.au or contact us using the secure methods detailed here: https://www.crikey.com.au/tip-off-crikey/Subscribe to Crikey now to get 60% off your annual subscription! https://campaigns.crikey.com.au/subscribe
  • Can One Nation clean up in Victoria? Antony Green gives his verdict

    36:59|
    With Victorians going to the ballot box in just a few weeks, the story of this state election is already being written. One Nation, the Coalition and Labor are neck and neck in some polls, so is a change of government inevitable? This week on Cut Through, Antony Green, ABC election legend and Crikey contributor joins our politics editor Bernard Keane and Rachel Withers to talk about the most significant state election in decades, the key seats to watch – and what One Nation’s chances really are of scooping up major party losses.Plus, are predictions of a Labor wipe-out unfounded?Today’s episode covers:How significant is the Victorian state election?Ones to watch: the biggest contests on November 28Problems One Nation will face at the ballot boxJess Wilson’s chances of scooping up key seatsLessons from South AustraliaWhy independents will struggle this time roundWill Labor’s red wall in Melbourne’s west fall to One Nation?The Greens chances of going double-digitsRead the transcript here, watch or listen to the episode above.READ MORE:Could the Greens flip these ‘sleeper’ seats in Victoria?Where the teals at? Independents face a tough battle in Victoria — but don’t count them outCan this new party win seats off Labor in Melbourne’s neglected western suburbs?Want to ask us a question? Send an email to letters@crikey.com.au or contact us using the secure methods detailed here: https://www.crikey.com.au/tip-off-crikey/ Subscribe to Crikey now to get 60% off your annual subscription! https://campaigns.crikey.com.au/subscribeWant to ask us a question? Send an email to letters@crikey.com.au or contact us using the secure methods detailed here.Subscribe to Crikey now to get 60% off your annual subscription!
  • A new Green stone in Albo's Shoe(Bridge)

    37:44|
    Parliament is back in session, and there’s a new Greens leader on the scene to cause trouble for Anthony Albanese. Crikey’s politics reporter Anton Nilsson and journalist Tina Quinn discuss how Labor’s agenda is holding up against attacks from all sides.Plus, Josh Frydenberg’s incredible comeback story gets better every time, and how the scourge of “drops” to favourable journalists weakens the media and lets politicians off scot-free.Today’s episode covers:Digital Duty of Care bill and the Liberal Party’s picky relationship with “free speech”America’s “extraordinary” intervention in Australian tech legislationCan Labor and David Shoebridge get along?Will Angus Taylor’s “war on small business” attack lay a glove on Labor?(Another) great Josh Frydenberg comeback storyThe scourge of political drops and “horse race journalism” Read the transcript here, watch or listen to the episode above.Want to ask us a question? Send an email to letters@crikey.com.au or contact us using the secure methods detailed here.Read more:‘Addicted to drops’: Insiders spill on why Australian media is silent on One Nation’s press ban‘People are human’: David Shoebridge on leadership rival tensions, a Labor alliance, and the Greens’ futureDebt-king Josh Frydenberg was a terrible treasurer — but he’s right on GSTWant to ask us a question? Send an email to letters@crikey.com.au or contact us using the secure methods detailed here: https://www.crikey.com.au/tip-off-crikey/ Subscribe to Crikey now to get 60% off your annual subscription!
  • Is the ‘Nerd Reich’ gaslighting Australia on data centres?

    36:22|
    In a special Q&A episode of Cut Through, Rachel puts your questions to long-time Crikey contributors, climate analyst Ketan Joshi and Dr Ben Eltham, about the unfortunate topic de jour: the rapid proliferation of data centres. What are they? Do we actually need them? And what is the benefit — if any — of having them operate on Australian soil?Plus, the AI wins we’ve had so far, and how this is a critical time in the battle against the normalisation of energy-guzzling, slop-producing data warehouses.Today’s episode covers:What exactly is a data centre and do we need them?Artificial intelligence, energy use and personal responsibility Does Australia actually benefit from housing data centres?“Sovereignty-washing” and the lie of frontier modelsHow the rest of the world is dealing with data centresThe best-case scenario Read the transcript here, watch or listen to the episode above.Want to ask us a question? Send an email to letters@crikey.com.au or contact us using the secure methods detailed here.Read more:Canberra is ‘drinking the Kool-Aid’ on AI. Where will it take us?Doomsday AI cultists aren’t just good marketers — they’re capturing governmentsWhat Ireland’s cautionary tale on data centres can teach AustraliaNVIDIA’S AI Climate hoaxWant to ask us a question? Send an email to letters@crikey.com.au or contact us using the secure methods detailed here: https://www.crikey.com.au/tip-off-crikey/ Subscribe to Crikey now to get 60% off your annual subscription!
  • Behind the scenes of Barnaby's neo-Nazi run-in, NACC emails and Mamamia blowback

    43:58|
    It’s been a busy month for our tips hog, Cochon Truffier. The intrepid pig snooped out some internal discussions between NACC staffers which probably should have been had at the pub, investigated the backlash to Mia Freedman’s comments about the Ed Sheeran/Macklemore saga, and dug into why student politicians at Sydney Uni were getting their knickers in a knot over allegations involving horse meat and bribery in Kazakhstan.Plus, we take you behind the scenes of Barnaby Joyce’s run-in with a neo-Nazi at Canberra Casino, and look at how One Nation candidates in Victoria just can’t get their resumes right. Today’s episode covers:Why Barnaby went to “friendly” media rather than respond to Crikey over casino sagaOne Nation candidates and their sometimes inaccurate biosMia Freedman feels the heat from Mamamia’s Facebook fans over PalestineLocker room chat at the NACCThe saga of Sydney Uni politics, horse meat and Kazakh bribesRead more:Crikey asked Barnaby Joyce about a neo-Nazi encounter at a casino. His response shows how politics and media workA star One Nation candidate said he was a criminal lawyer. There’s no record of thatThe Snoop: News24’s unfortunate uniform, Mamamia’s audience backlash on Gaza, and moreThe Snoop: NACC’s internal messages revealed, 7.30’s foreign policy ‘bias’, and moreThe Snoop: One Nation candidate claims ‘witch hunt’, NFL’s play for Blinky Bill, and moreWant to ask us a question? Send an email to letters@crikey.com.au or contact us using the secure methods detailed here: https://www.crikey.com.au/tip-off-crikey/ Subscribe to Crikey now to get 60% off your annual subscription!
  • Revisiting Paul Keating’s legacy: Australian foreign policy and national identity

    37:42|
    Paul Keating was prime minister of a very different Australia, in a very different geopolitical environment from that of today. How does his ambition for Australia hold up 30 years later? Crikey politics editor Bernard Keane and Professor James Curran from the University of Sydney discuss Keating’s legacy, and whether his approach to foreign policy suffered from the curse of being “right, but too early”.Today’s episode covers:Shaping foreign policy in a post-Cold War worldWinston Churchill’s influence on KeatingAustralia and Asia under KeatingIndonesian President Suharto’s impact on KeatingReimagining Australia’s national identityKeating’s view of the US alliance: then and nowSliding doors: The 1996 election lossRead more:Grand Ambition: Paul Keating's global vision for Australia by James CurranPaul Keating and a very present past raise hard questions for a country of decidedly modest ambitionWant to ask us a question? Send an email to letters@crikey.com.au or contact us using the secure methods detailed here: https://www.crikey.com.au/tip-off-crikey/.Subscribe to Crikey now to get 55% off your annual subscription!