Caviar and Criminals

Before we disappear for a little summer break, we're giving one of our favorite episodes a fresh cut. (Too soon?)This week, we're re-releasing our unforgettable deep dive into the story of Lorena Bobbitt, as Dana walks Anthony through one of the most sensational, misunderstood, and endlessly talked-about true crime cases of the '90s. It's a story that's far more complicated than the headlines—and yes, we still have plenty to say about that night.Whether you're hearing it for the first time or coming back for another listen, we hope you enjoy this revamped episode while we soak up a little summer.We'll be back before you know it with Season 4—featuring brand-new stories, more outrageous history, shocking true crime, pop culture chaos, and all the laughs you've come to expect.Have an amazing summer, and we'll see you soon.

This week, Anthony tells Dana the shocking story of Robert Kissel, a wealthy investment banker whose seemingly picture-perfect life ended in one of Hong Kong's most infamous murder cases. What started as an elite power couple with enviable careers unraveled into a tale of betrayal, deception, and one very infamous milkshake.As Anthony breaks down the case, Dana tries to make sense of the lies, the motive, and the courtroom drama that captivated the world. Was it a desperate act, a calculated plan, or something far more complicated?Grab your favorite drink—maybe not a milkshake—and join us for a wild ride through one of true crime's most bizarre and unforgettable cases.Listen now wherever you get your podcasts!

This week, Dana takes Anthony through the extraordinary life of Howard Ashman—the brilliant lyricist and creative force behind Little Shop of Horrors, The Little Mermaid, Beauty and the Beast, and Aladdin. From transforming musical theater to helping launch the Disney Renaissance, Howard's talent changed animation forever.But behind the unforgettable songs was a heartbreaking story of love, ambition, and resilience. Dana unpacks Howard's career, his creative partnership with Alan Menken, his battle with AIDS during one of the most pivotal moments in Disney history, and the legacy he left behind despite a life cut tragically short.It's equal parts hilarious, emotional, and inspiring—because sometimes the people who leave the biggest mark on the world don't get nearly enough credit.Listen now wherever you get your podcasts!

This week, we're asking the question no one should be asking: was Anthony Curcio really the hottest bank robber ever?Anthony walks Dana through the bizarre true story of Anthony Curcio—a former high school football star turned armored car robber whose elaborate heist involved fake construction crews, Craigslist ads, and one very memorable escape plan. It's clever, chaotic, and proof that even the best plans can fall apart in the most ridiculous ways.Come for the "hot criminal" debate, stay for one of the wildest heists you've probably never heard about.

This week, Dana brings Anthony the full story of Polari — where it came from, how it worked, who carried it, and what happened when the law finally changed and the language no longer had to hide. From underground queer venues and West End theatres to a BBC radio comedy that was hiding a secret in front of fifteen million listeners, Polari is the story of a community that refused to disappear, even when the world demanded they become invisible.It's Pride month on Caviar & Criminals. And this one is for everyone who's ever had to speak in code just to be themselves.

This week,Anthony and Dana take us to two very different chapters of LGBTQ+ history.First, Anthony tells the story of Operation Soap, the infamous 1981 police raids on Toronto bathhouses that resulted in the arrests of hundreds of gay men. Often described as Canada's Stonewall, the raids sparked outrage, galvanized a movement, and transformed the fight for LGBTQ+ rights across the country. What began as a coordinated attack on a marginalized community became a catalyst for one of the most important moments in Canadian queer history.Then, Dana explores the often-overlooked role of Italian Americans in the early Pride movement in New York City. From activists and organizers to neighborhood allies navigating cultural and religious expectations, she uncovers the stories of Italian Americans who helped shape the growing movement for gay liberation in the years following Stonewall.From police raids and public protests to community organizing and cultural identity, this episode examines how ordinary people pushed back against discrimination and helped build the foundation for LGBTQ+ rights as we know them today.

This Pride Month, we're revisiting one of our favorite episodes celebrating two men who changed history in very different ways.Anthony tells the story of Harvey Milk, the trailblazing politician who became one of the first openly gay elected officials in the United States and inspired a generation to step out of the shadows and into public life. His fight for visibility, equality, and representation would leave a lasting mark on the LGBTQ+ rights movement.Then Dana takes us through the remarkable and heartbreaking story of Alan Turing, the brilliant mathematician whose work helped win World War II, laid the foundation for modern computing, and ultimately changed the world. Despite his extraordinary contributions, Turing faced persecution simply for being who he was.From City Hall to codebreaking, from activism to innovation, this special Pride Month re-release honors two icons whose courage, brilliance, and sacrifices continue to shape the world we live in today.Because sometimes the people who change history aren't just fighting to be remembered — they're fighting to be allowed to exist.

A love triangle, a mysterious blonde in a black coat, and a murder that shocked suburban New York. This week, Anthony takes Dana through the wild and messy case of Carolyn Warmus — the so-called “Fatal Attraction Killer” whose affair with a married man ended in obsession, scandal, and a courtroom drama straight out of a movie.Was Carolyn a cold-blooded murderer? A woman unfairly villainized? Or is there more to the story than the headlines wanted us to believe? Tune in for one of the most infamous cases of obsession and murder — and listen to Caviar and Criminals wherever you get your podcasts.