Share

cover art for Cherish Oppenheim

Canadian True Crime

Cherish Oppenheim

Ep. 158

The case of a beloved 16-year-old girl who didn't return home one night—and the many questionable decisions made by authorities that could have inadvertently saved her life.


The intention of this episode is to highlight how cases involving missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls are often treated differently at every stage of the criminal justice process, as per Reclaiming Power and Place, the final report of the National Inquiry into #MMIWG.


Additional content warning: this episode is about the murder and possible sexual assault of an underage girl.


This month, Canadian True Crime has donated to Justice for Girls Outreach Society


Full list of resources, information sources and credits:

See the page for this episode at www.canadiantruecrime.ca/episodes 

More episodes

View all episodes

  • 168. Collision Course: The Darcy Allan Sheppard Case [4]

    01:14:12||Ep. 168
    [ Part 4 of 4 ] The TruthHidden documents and files are released through a Freedom of Information request, strongly suggesting that what actually happened on August 31, 2009 was different to the narrative presented by the press — and in court.In this new four-part series, edited and re-mastered, you’ll hear a story of elites vs peasants, cars vs bicycles, and wealth and privilege vs poverty and crime. It’s a cautionary tale of how justice works differently in this country for some people.Listen ad-free and early: The entire series is available ad-free on our premium feeds - Amazon Music (included with Prime), Apple Podcasts, Patreon and Supercast.INVITATION: 15th Annual Memorial Gathering - TorontoPlease join us Saturday, August 31 at 3 p.m. at the spot where Darcy died at 151 Bloor Street West. There’s a white Ghost Bike opposite Tiffany & Co and close to Bloor St and Avenue Road.Special thanks to Allan Sheppard, Joe Hendry and Victoria (the eyewitness). Thanks also to writer Mary Fairhurst Breen for editing and creative direction on this reboot series.Please respect the privacy of those involved in this case.Full list of information sources, resources and credits:All the documents, evidence, statements, reports and news articles we’ve relied upon to write this series are available at www.canadiantruecrime.ca/episodes/darcy.
  • 167. Collision Course: The Darcy Allan Sheppard Case [3]

    01:09:06||Ep. 167
    [ Part 3 of 4 ] How the Justice System FailedThe controversial 2010 hearing where the prosecutor announced his decision to withdraw charges. While Darcy’s father expected that result, something seemed significantly wrong with how the prosecutor chose to explain how the decision was made. In this new four-part series, edited and re-mastered, you’ll hear a story of elites vs peasants, cars vs bicycles, and wealth and privilege vs poverty and crime. It’s a cautionary tale of how justice works differently in this country for some people.Listen ad-free and early: The entire series is available ad-free on our premium feeds - Amazon Music (included with Prime), Apple Podcasts, Patreon and Supercast.__________________________________________________INVITATION: 15th Annual Memorial Gathering - TorontoPlease join us Saturday, August 31 at 3 p.m. at the spot where Darcy died at 151 Bloor Street West. There’s a white Ghost Bike opposite Tiffany & Co and close to Bloor St and Avenue Road.__________________________________________________Special thanks to Allan Sheppard, Joe Hendry and Victoria (the eyewitness). Thanks also to writer Mary Fairhurst Breen for editing and creative direction on this reboot series.Please respect the privacy of those involved in this case.Full list of information sources, resources and credits:All the documents, evidence, statements, reports and news articles we’ve relied upon to write this series are available at www.canadiantruecrime.ca/episodes/darcy.
  • 166. Collision Course: The Darcy Allan Sheppard Case [2]

    01:05:49||Ep. 166
    [ Part 2 of 4 ] How the Media FailedIn the wake of Darcy’s death, a crisis PR firm succeeds in influencing the media – and public perception – with misleading and false information.In this new four-part series, edited and re-mastered, you’ll hear a story of elites vs peasants, cars vs bicycles, and wealth and privilege vs poverty and crime. It’s a cautionary tale of how justice works differently in this country for some people.Release schedule: New episodes each day with the final episode on Friday August 23.Listen ad-free and early: The entire series is available ad-free on our premium feeds - Amazon Music (included with Prime), Apple Podcasts, Patreon and Supercast.INVITATION: 15th Annual Memorial Gathering - TorontoPlease join us Saturday, August 31 at 3 p.m. at the spot where Darcy died at 151 Bloor Street West. There’s a white Ghost Bike opposite Tiffany & Co and close to Bloor St and Avenue Road.Special thanks to Allan Sheppard, Joe Hendry and Victoria (the eyewitness). Thanks also to writer Mary Fairhurst Breen for editing and creative direction on this reboot series.Please respect the privacy of those involved in this case.Full list of information sources, resources and credits:All the documents, evidence, statements, reports and news articles we’ve relied upon to write this series are available at www.canadiantruecrime.ca/episodes/darcy.
  • 165. Collision Course: The Darcy Allan Sheppard Case [1]

    01:03:41||Ep. 165
    TORONTO - A special new presentation to commemorate the 15th anniversary of the controversial death of Toronto bike messenger Darcy Allan Sheppard.[ Part 1 of 4 ] Sheppard v BryantOn August 31, 2009, there was a catastrophic collision between a cyclist and a motorist on a busy downtown Toronto street — a collision so unfathomable that it shocked bystanders and the city at large. Darcy Allan Sheppard died on the street that night. The motorist, former Ontario Attorney General Michael Bryant was arrested, charged, and released the next morning. The way the case unfolded in the media – and the justice system – would be hotly debated for years to come.In this new four-part series, edited and re-mastered, you’ll hear a story of elites vs peasants, cars vs bicycles, and wealth and privilege vs poverty and crime. It’s a cautionary tale of how justice works differently in this country for some people.Release schedule: New episodes each day with the final episode on Friday August 23.Listen ad-free and early: The entire series will be available ad-free on our premium feeds within 24 hours - Amazon Music (included with Prime), Apple Podcasts, Patreon and Supercast.INVITATION: 15th Annual Memorial Gathering - TorontoPlease join us Saturday, August 31 at 3 p.m. at the spot where Darcy died at 151 Bloor Street West. There’s a white Ghost Bike opposite Tiffany & Co and close to Bloor St and Avenue Road.Special thanks to Allan Sheppard, Joe Hendry and Victoria (the eyewitness). Thanks also to writer Mary Fairhurst Breen for editing and creative direction on this reboot series.Please respect the privacy of those involved in this case.Full list of information sources, resources and credits:All the documents, evidence, statements, reports and news articles we’ve relied upon to write this series are available at www.canadiantruecrime.ca/episodes/darcy.
  • 164. Special Announcement and Invitation

    04:59||Ep. 164
    Hi there, our new season starts on September 9. But for now...Darcy Allan Sheppard Updates: 15th Annual Memorial Gathering - please join us:Date and time: Saturday, August 31, 3 p.m. Location: 151 Bloor Street West, Ghost Bike opposite Tiffany & Co. Close to Bloor St and Avenue Road.Release of new series:Starting tomorrow through Friday, we'll be releasing a new, re-mastered and edited version of our original series from 2022 to commemorate the anniversary.More information: www.canadiantruecrime.ca/episodes/darcyApple Podcasts ‘Creators We Love’ featureYou can find it on the Apple Podcasts Browse Page or the True Crime category page - don’t forget to tap the “subscribe” button so you don’t miss an episode! About the podcast About Kristi Lee We'll be back with the first episode in our new season on September 9. See you then!
  • 163. Major Case Updates 2024 — Part 2

    01:14:44||Ep. 163
    [Part 2 of 2] Featuring interviews with survivors Josh Whiteway and Kerri Kehoe, we continue to look back at cases we've covered with major updates in past years.Approximate timestamps (Give or take a few minutes depending on ad breaks)1:30 Lush & Whiteway Families car crash (update from Josh Whiteway)9:00 Jacob Hoggard updates16:00 The Kingston Cases (update from Kerri Kehoe re Richard Charles Joyce)30:00 Legacy Christian Academy and Mile Two Church Scandal #legacyofabuse54:00 Kelly Ellard Sim's latest parole hearing (murder of Reena Virk)1:03:00 Albert Johnson Walker's latest parole hearing (murder of Ronald Platt)1:09:00 The Shell Lake Massacre - new details in new podcastMore information:Crime Beat TV - subscribe on youtube for the return of Season 6 in the fall featuring Kerri Kehoe and the "Kingston Cases"The Shell Lake Massacre - new podcast series from Rawlco RadioLegacy of Abuse - support the former students of Legacy Christian AcademyListen ad-free and early:CTC premium feeds are available on Amazon Music (included with Prime), Apple Podcasts, Patreon and Supercast, giving you access 24 hours early without the ads. Please note: case-based episodes will always be available to all, we will never put them exclusively behind a paywall.Full list of resources, information sources and credits:See the page for this episode at www.canadiantruecrime.ca/episodes 
  • 162. Major Case Updates 2024 — Part 1

    01:17:32||Ep. 162
    [Part 1 of 2] This two-part series will report back on the cases we’ve covered that have had major updates over the past years.Approximate timestamps (Give or take a few minutes depending on ad breaks)7:00 Robert Pickton13:00 Renfrew County Massacre20:00 Madison Scott23:00 Dellen Millard and Mark Smich28:00 Multiple Murders / Consecutive sentences33:00 The Harrison Family Murders44:00 The Brentwood Five53:00 Paul Bernardo1:06:00 Use of AI Voices - update and feedbackMore information on previous Canadian True Crime episodes:Klaus Family MurdersSara and TaliyahMadison Scott - public plea for new informationListen ad-free and early:CTC premium feeds are available on Amazon Music (included with Prime), Apple Podcasts, Patreon and Supercast, giving you access 24 hours early without the ads. Please note: case-based episodes will always be available to all, we will never put them exclusively behind a paywall.Full list of resources, information sources and credits:See the page for this episode at www.canadiantruecrime.ca/episodes 
  • 161. Susan Klassen

    01:24:16||Ep. 161
    36-year old Susan Klassen had only lived in Whitehorse for a few years, but she made a considerable impact on the local community as a renowned modern storyteller with the Yukon International Storytelling Festival. Susan’s death—and the public outrage that followed—was named the #1 story in the Yukon for 1997.“Throughout her life, she deeply touched the lives and hearts of many. Along with her love of nature, one of Susan’s greatest joys was to share her talent of storytelling.” - ObituaryIf you or a loved one is experiencing family violence, help and resources are available. Support Services - Canadian Women's FoundationFind family violence resources and services in your area - Canada.ca----------------------------------------------------This episode is about an important case that became a watershed moment for the local community in Whitehorse, Yukon, and across the country. We’ve pieced it together from court documents and the news archives, most notably the reporting of Caroline Murray and Yvette Brend for the Whitehorse Daily Star. Our sincere condolences to Susan Klassen’s loved ones and anyone else affected by this crime. ----------------------------------------------------Canadian True Crime has donated to Kaushee’s Place; a transition home for women and gender diverse people experiencing violence in the Yukon.True Crime and Paranormal Podcast FestivalJuly 12-14, Denver, Colorado. Use code KRISTI for 15% discount off ticket prices.www.truecrimepodcastfestival.comFull list of resources, information sources and credits:See the page for this episode at www.canadiantruecrime.ca/episodes
  • 160. Kimberly Proctor — Part 2

    01:29:26||Ep. 160
    Part 2 of 2] The murder of 18-year-old Kimberly Proctor shocked her community and made national headlines. But as investigators soon discovered, there were many red flags and warning signs that weren’t taken seriously.Through this series, we utilize case files released by police as well as relevant studies, statistics and scholarly articles to examine a number of issues related to the dynamics of teenage relationships in the online era. Our goal is to highlight common manipulation tactics employed by abusive people, the pitfalls of navigating consent, boundaries and rejection, mental health, nature vs nurture and more. This series is closely related to our previous episode titled Cherish.Additional content warning: this series includes graphic and distressing details of a murder and sexual assault, and while not the focus of the case there is brief mention of sexual assault against a child and cruelty to animals. Please respect the privacy of those involved in this case.This month, Canadian True Crime has donated in Kimberly’s memory to BC SPCA Wild Arc, the wildlife rescue organization she planned to start volunteering with.Full list of resources, information sources and credits:See the page for this episode at www.canadiantruecrime.ca/episodes