Watch the full and ad-free interview HERE: https://open.substack.com/pub/thebrinkpodcast/p/whos-the-real-winner-air-marshal?r=63dafp&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true
In this episode of The Brink, Andrew and Jake are joined by Air Marshall Edward Stringer, for a timely and wide-ranging conversation on Iran, NATO, and the future of Western power.
We explore the question at the heart of today’s conflicts: who is actually winning? Against the backdrop of rising tensions with Iran and a shifting global order, Stringer challenges the idea that military strikes alone can deliver lasting outcomes, arguing that without a clear political end state, even successful operations risk achieving very little.
The discussion looks at the limits of air power and modern warfare, and why technological superiority is no substitute for coherent strategy. Stringer explains how interventions can shape events in the short term, but cannot create stability on their own, raising serious questions about recent Western actions in the Middle East.
We also examine the state of NATO and Western defence more broadly. Stringer warns that capabilities have declined significantly, with the UK and its allies falling behind in readiness and resilience, even as threats become more immediate and complex.
Finally, the conversation turns to the bigger picture. From Iran and global energy security to the role of allies and so-called middle powers, this episode asks whether the West is entering a period of strategic drift and what it would take to reverse that trajectory.
A clear-eyed and thought-provoking discussion on war, power, and the future of the West.
Don't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/
Chapters
00:00 Introduction
02:36 Stringer’s Military Background & Experience
05:04 The Libya Campaign Explained
07:51 Libya: Did Air Power Really Work?
09:00 Why You Can’t “Bomb Your Way To Victory”
15:39 Iran Today: What Does “Success” Look Like?
19:26 Was War With Iran Inevitable?
20:16 Can Air Power Ever Deliver Regime Change?
25:51 Trump’s War Rhetoric & Its Consequences
28:07 Social Media, War & Political Messaging
31:21 The Problem With US Global Leadership
35:49 Has The US Always Controlled NATO?
38:07 Europe’s Military Weakness Explained
40:31 Will Things “Go Back To Normal” After Trump?
41:57 A Fundamental Shift In Global Power
43:26 Has The UK Fallen Behind On Defence?
","author_name":"The Brink "}