Hibs didn’t just lose to St Johnstone, they looked coached out of the game. Matty and Colin pick apart a flat, lifeless performance, the worrying lack of cohesion, and the bigger question now hanging over David Gray: is this a blip, or the start of the end?
The mood is brutal because there are no easy excuses left. From the passive first half and the sloppy defending to the cheap penalty and the failure to react after the break, this is the kind of performance that turns frustration into real pressure. And when your own supporters are already debating whether the manager has run out of road, every mistake starts to feel bigger.
You’ll hear them break down:
Why the lineup looked reasonable on paper but never clicked on the pitch
The defensive mess that led to the opening goal
Low’s bright moments, including a smart finish that briefly got Hibs back in it
Why the midfield shape, especially Chaiwa, McGrath, Mulligan and Devaney, still feels wrong
The growing concern that the problem is not just players having off days, but something deeper in the coaching and setup
They also dig into the wider stakes: the angry reaction from supporters, the recurring criticism that nothing has changed from last season, and the uncomfortable reality that Hibs now face a huge cup tie at Ross County with pressure rising fast. If you think the issue is only one bad result, this episode makes the case that the cracks go much deeper than that.
Essential listening if you’re trying to make sense of a team that can look decent one week and completely lost the next, and if you want the raw, unfiltered fan reaction to a defeat that may have changed the conversation around David Gray for good.
","author_name":"Longbangers"}