Share

cover art for Is Pluribus Too Smart for us?

Five Dollar Tuesdays Podcast

Is Pluribus Too Smart for us?

Ep. 15
•

Vince Gilligan is officially back, and he’s cooking on a level most audiences aren't prepared for. This episode breaks down Pluribus, the sci-fi epic that has sparked a massive debate: Is it a slow-burn masterpiece, or is modern media illiteracy finally reaching its peak?


00:00 Hype Cold Open

00:19 Show Premise Setup

01:29 Signal And Hive Mind

02:44 Why It Feels Real

06:40 Cinematography And Pacing

09:21 Rhea Seehorn Spotlight

13:16 Absurdity With Restraint

19:08 Carol Arc And Finale

22:12 Intro Song And Harmony

25:19 AI Parable Angle

26:39 Why People Hate It

27:33 Attention Spans And Trash TV

38:37 Craft Ethos Behind Scenes

42:42 Streaming Slop Rant

44:11 Apple TV New HBO

45:38 Cable Era Nostalgia

47:05 Franchise Fatigue

48:25 Mystery Rules Unfold

50:27 Carol Versus Hive

52:46 Morality Without Preaching

56:15 Craft Masterclass Praise

57:37 Best Lines Breakdown

01:11:34 Season Two Hopes

01:14:39 Origin Clues Chemtrails

01:19:39 Final Thoughts Watch It

More episodes

View all episodes

  • The Weirdest Halloween Episode on Television

    15:25|
    Shawn forced the gang to sit through an 11-minute deep dive into pumpkin mortality, Buick sedans, and warm apples, and Wilson is audibly losing his will to live. We break down whether Joe Pera’s fall loop is a deadpan, melancholic masterpiece or just the weirdest way to ruin a Tuesday before recording.
  • 19. They Live: Capitalism, Cocaine Promos, and Alleyway Brawls

    38:59||Ep. 19
    We gave up waiting five months for Shawn to let us watch his precious Blu-ray and tackled John Carpenter’s They Live this Halloween season. Armed with an unhinged wrestling icon, a punk rock attitude, and a fifteen-minute alleyway brawl over basic eyewear, it turns out an 80s B-movie understood our brain-rotted, ad-choked dystopia far better than we do. Put the damn glasses on, obey, and hit play.
  • 18. I, Robot (2004): Janky CGI & the Invention of JerkDash

    42:58||Ep. 18
    We sat through two hours of 2004's I, Robot so you never have to catch it on cable again. We break down Will Smith’s leather-clad boomer era, draining Lake Michigan for data centers, and how a generic sci-fi mystery could have done something more interesting like predicting the future of "JerkDash" delivery. Come for the blockbuster slander, stay for Wilson confusing Glen Powell with the Secretary of State.
  • 17. TMNT (1990 and 2014): There's No Secret in This Ooze

    53:48||Ep. 17
    Drowning their motion-sickness in Twisted Tea, Lee, Wilson and Shawn tear into the 2014 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles as a nauseating, piss-green, ad-riddled cash grab featuring terrifying CGI monsters, a completely unbothered Megan Fox, and a general contempt for children's intelligence- all while longing for the charm, patience, and actual heart of the 1990 original.
  • 16. Drunkdevil: A Missed Opportunity

    28:27||Ep. 16
    If you stumbled onto this video hoping for polished, video essay-style cinematic analysis... we are so deeply sorry. This is just three guys getting wasted and talking about superhero trash that nobody cares about.Like, subscribe, and please send help.
  • 14. Prometheus: Misunderstood Masterpiece or Hot Mess?

    30:06||Ep. 14
    Hear us out, Prometheus is a filmmaker's film.00:00 Introduction to Ridley Scott's Creative Freedom00:48 Prometheus: A Misunderstood Masterpiece02:03 The Extended Universe and Unanswered Questions03:51 Philosophical Themes and Character Critiques08:25 Comparisons to the Original Alien Series13:20 Ridley Scott's Legacy and Missteps16:03 Lost in the Woods: Understanding the Film's Intentions16:59 The Ridley Cut: Director's Vision and Science Fiction Elements18:00 Dissecting Audience Reactions and Reviews19:25 Philosophical Themes and Character Analysis22:01 Comparing Prometheus and Alien: Legacy and Impact26:25 Final Thoughts: The Future of the Franchise and Film Industry
  • 12. A Very Wilson Christmas: The Muppet Christmas Carol

    43:28||Ep. 12
    Join us for a holiday special where Wilson reveals his disdain for Christmas but finds himself surprisingly charmed by 'The Muppet Christmas Carol.' Despite never having seen the Muppets before, he and the boys delve into the film's production, Michael Caine's stellar performance, and why modern holiday "content" lacks the heart and soul of this 1992 classic.
  • 11. LITERALLY DESTROYED: An Under Siege Review

    45:14||Ep. 11
    In this episode, the boys take a deep dive into 'Under Siege'—allegedly Steven Seagal's finest work. You'll learn about Seagal's questionable acting chops, Tommy Lee Jones' over-the-top villain role, and of course, Gary Busey in drag. In the end, the boys grapple with why producers thought Seagal could ever be a leading action star, and come to the surprising conclusion that this 'Die-Hard-on-a-boat' spectacle is a decent movie in spite of him. So grab a beer and join the boys in the garage—it's an adventure, man!